I'll do a thread about detransition, why not?
Show this thread
-
Those arguments are valid enough that I would agree that studies have under counted detransitioners, more likely than not. But then, I would encourage you to ask: By how much have they undercounted, do we think?
Show this thread
Forget study methods for a minute, and come with me to a place I like to call The Real World. In The Real World, patients get prescribed a medication or undergo medical procedures, and doctors follow up to a greater or lesser extent.
-
-
In The Real World, doctors don't see most patients throughout their whole lives, and are more likely to see them when there is a problem. Studies are helpful in quantifying if there are more complications than docs realize, or results are less favorable than they hoped.
Show this thread -
What studies DON'T generally show is a massive numbers of patients who were extremely dissatisfied with a procedure, to the point of blaming the doctor who performed it, while the doctor remained totally unaware that there were any problems at all.
Show this thread -
It is perfectly sensible to say, okay, the data shows less than 1% of patients detransition... but maybe it's something more like 2-3%.
Show this thread -
It is NOT sensible to say okay, the data shows less than 1% of patients detransition, but eff that, it's probably 30% because I personally detransitioned, or because I personally have a hunch trans people will have regrets.
Show this thread -
Common sense tells us that it's easy to meet trans people who have stayed transitioned for decades, who have lived most of their lives post-transition, and it's hard to find detransitioners. Sooo... maybe detransition is rare? And, look, the studies back that up.
Show this thread -
So, the bottom line is that anyone who posits a huge number of hiding, quiet detransitioners that no study has ever been able to find is not using Occam's razor, or science. They're basing it on prejudice.
Show this thread -
In summary: It's perfectly rational to believe that detransitioners are undercounted in studies that find extremely low numbers. It is irrational to believe they are massively undercounted to the point where it would change our understanding of transition or trans lives.
Show this thread -
And, people who are invested in there being massive numbers of detransitioners often try to fudge things so that an AFAB who wears a baseball cap for a while, then stops, is a detransitioner instead of sticking to people who take permanent, long term transition steps.
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.