his response to a different author who is the probably the original source where this person got the mischaracterization fromhttps://jordanbpeterson.com/uncategorized/response-to-vox-feminist-philosopher-dr-kate-manne-of-cornell/ …
-
-
maybe I'm misunderstanding your perspective? I don't want to do that. To me it looks like a deliberate malicious misreading that explicitly omits important context.
-
I'd say that's at least 50% likely but there's just not sufficient info to say w/o the primary source
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
I'm waiting to see how clear the primary text makes this, if it's left ambiguous at all that's sorta on him
-
Tweet unavailable
-
I'm basically just waiting on https://twitter.com/Manathemist/status/1006966486248886272?s=19 …
This Tweet is unavailable.
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
1/My reactions: (i) you can publish anonymized case reports. Best practice is to get the person's consent & mix up details (or use composite) so they're not identifiable. (ii) There may be credibility-related reasons, beyond those disclosed in Jordan's text, to doubt the woman
-
2/was raped. Importantly, though, if the same type of thing has happened to the woman five times, and always after heavily drinking then going to a secluded area with a man intent on sex, and she suspected rape, I'd try to do everything in my power (qua therapist) to get her to
-
3/stop drinking heavily, esp. in circumstances (no reliable friends around, etc.) likely to lead to being in an isolated place with a man intent on sex; and, (iii) there are false positives with respect to both rape and child sexual abuse, and our social response (both cultural &
-
4/legal) have the potential to influence both the true incidence rate & the false positive rate. I'd expect the apparent injunction that all rape / child abuse accusers must be believed to increase the false rape report rate, thus making people who had actually been raped less
-
5/credible, all else equal. & we've seen instances of moral panics over purported childhood sexual abuse (e.g., the "Satanic Abuse" cases) where dads indeed suffered greatly over false reports & fabricated memories. Reductive slogans help little!
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.