maybe if you repeat "aww sumbuddy hurt ur widdle feefees and you turned into a nazi" at them enough times they'll decide that's what happened good plan, definitely not a preaching to the choir power signalling exercise
some people don't think any elements of society need to be forcefully suppressed, and also that speaking of people as "elements of society" first is an atrocity-producing framing. past that, is that heuristic any good now that any three outgroup markers i don't like = nazi?
-
-
"some people don't think any elements of society need to be forcefully suppressed" very few people actually believe that, not even most anarchists. and yeah if you have a better heuristic for producing atrocities, it is badly needed
-
i mean if i were tempted to forcefully suppress some motherfuckers i might look to outright advocacy of genocide and de jure caste division
-
there's too few of those to produce a credible enough threat to maintain a power base with though
-
well anyone who openly advocates genocide when such a thing is being suppressed is almost by definition not a real threat -if there is one, it's from those who advocate it with plausible deniability almost as if fascism is a really big problem for liberalism idk
-
right, so now we're assigning people to the category "nazi" based on what we've decided they really mean, so it's instantly at best 10% potentially effective praxis against a real threat, 90% bludgeon to punish the outgroup with
-
idk where you're getting that distribution from (as I said, open genocide advocates aren't the real threat to begin with), but apart fro that, yes, who doesn't wanna bludgeon the outgroup. doesn't mean it can play out any other way though
-
that's Sturgeon's Distribution yo yeah spose, the list of factuals you have to pretend are counterfactuals in order to not get outgrouped is getting real fucking long though
-
well getting call-outs from specific sub-communities within the left isn't quite the same as being considered a nazi imo, but yeah, and the only thing that can be done against that is pushing back, being sectarian in turn, which also disrupts the power base
- 3 more replies
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.