The only way free will can work is if the Many worlds therom of quantum mechanics is true, and each conscious derision results in a new universe. And quantum mechanics means that most of these decisions are being made by particles, with life forms being pretentious bundles.
that's really better handled as an agency vs. coercion conversation, "free will" is just muddling it; by the actual usage of the term, you are still free willed in option 2, your free will cannot actually be removed, only your options can be constrained