I see being charitable as actually trying to see the value in what someone is doing even if you don’t agree with all or even most of their conclusions or methods, not saying “I believe they are sincere, yet deluded”
-
-
... like ur project and think it is great, even definitive. I think even the majority of snarky things James says in response to what I write have gotten positive responses. So u seem to have a lot of support from many people. I, too, gave positive feedback. And raised questions
-
... as well, that were actually primarily based on issues in the fields I know and work in, where I was saying that, hey, I'm not convinced this is a special problem w gender studies b/c a lot of bad stuff happens in my fields too.
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
I think it's mostly that there's a number of popular critiques that don't really make sense, like that they don't have a control for other fields (which they aren't even addressing), and that they preemptively addressed in the release and you've repeated at least one of those.
-
Yes and they keep going. I think the important thing is to acknowledge that Brian is an honest person who intended to be fair and balanced and honest because he now feels jumped on unfairly. We should move on with no hard feelings.
-
Happy 2 let this all go. Have unpinned tweets. I thought they could add value 2 discussion, pros&cons, ending w call 4 dialogue. But their continued existence on my page seems 2 elicit bad feelings & insistence I justify them. Have lost the whole day trying. Anyway, wish u well
-
Fair enough. Sorry it got so involved. I do look forward to your reading of the dog-humping paper, though, so I hope it doesn't all get let go.
-
I recommend the realpeerreview assessment of it too lol
-
They did well but missed some of the best stuff. I would love to have been there watching the person from their group who first found it, though. LOL
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
No. I let it go too coz so much going on and many more people making no effort to be balanced which you obviously were. I think we should let it go now. I have to go to sleep and then go talk to
@triggerpod in the morning. All is well. -
Good luck on your talk, I hope it goes well. I'll try to get some rest and start again for a new day tomorrow as well.
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.