... anyway, I already said in my original tweet that there *may* be an asymmetry in terms of average epistemological rigor required to publish in a top journal in gender studies vs. medicine, but your hoax doesn't show that. Just for a few examples, here is a paper in a ...
-
-
I'd suggest reading the reviewers' comments too. Just sayin'.
-
I did look through some of the comments that were posted. But I didn't get the impression that the full reviews were posted, just selections. I'll have to look again when I have some more time.
-
Here's a TL;DR of the dog-humping paper.https://twitter.com/RealPeerReview/status/1004805745068642304?s=19 …
- 1 more reply
New conversation -
-
-
Have you tried criticizing them yourself? Have you been dismissed as a misogynist if you say a peep against radical feminists? Have you been dismissed as suffering from white privilege and so you cannot possibly understand a topic? Told you should not write about certain topics?
-
By the way, these things have all happened to me. Dissent is treated as treason. If you have not experienced this yet, you have not yet interacted fully with these ideologues.
-
I didn't choose the above paper to critique at random either. This came out to the university from which I received my MA. I do believe you are looking at a "special problem" because a critique labels you a misogynist. Literally, that's what the author claims.
-
"It’s both ironic and fitting that my essay happened to be published in Feminist Media Studies in a commentary section on feminism and food media within a special issue on online misogyny."
-
"misogyny, which may not involve violence but almost always entails some form of harm; either directly in the form of psychological, professional, reputational, or, in some cases, physical harm; or indirectly, in the sense that it makes the internet a less equal, less safe" blah.
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.

