Conversation

Different static type systems offer different trade-offs, and most are far from perfect. If you ask people to adopt them then you are asking them to accept their failings in exchange for some some compelling super-powers, and a promise that they will be better in the future.
Quote Tweet
((Hopefully last thread on the "Maybe Not" talk)) I'm seeing a lot of people object with the following argument: 1. Hickey has problem X with type system A 2. Type system B doesn't have X => Hickey is wrong about static typing. This is a really common, and IMO poor, argument.
Show this thread
1
6
Personally I'm cool with the trade-off, but I've needed to make peace with the fact that there is no type system that will ever really satisfy me now. I'm optimistic that we are iterating towards a better place though. The future is exciting!
1
7
Sorry to bring all this up in people's timeline again - I guess I'm just hoping to encourage empathy and build some bridges! I'm not alone in forgetting that we're all trying to solve hard problems, in different ways!
2
3
No worries! Haven't seen much except for the Rich Hickey's gist about open source—seems somewhat sour but also understandable and possibly a bit of a hissy/hickey fit. I noticed your secret project in another tweet … so the future of programming _is_ dependently typed, isn't it?
1
Thankfully there are more resources than ever out there for people who want to learn how to work on dependently typed language implementations. The dominoes are starting to line up! It's an exciting time.
Replying to
Good luck with it! A lot of programs can be written easily within an ML-style system but would be nice to know you have the power of dependent types when you need it. I find DT pretty tricky in Haskell and haven't really gotten into them there... but in Idris, it's pretty easy.
1
Yeah - big thing I'm missing in Idris is low level control over memory representation. I also want it to be more structural too. Unfortunately the combination of these two things is hard, and dependent types add to the pain! For now I'm just not worrying too much... we'll see!
1
Show replies