There are some ways in which Narnia is better, mainly as Christian allegory, but it is inferior in a great many others. Tolkien was just better at world-building, deeper in his literary/historical/mythological influences than anybody else who has ever written in this field. https://twitter.com/BecketAdams/status/1254487480520368129 …
-
-
I, personally, would probably rank Narnia fourth among the great fantasy epic series I have read, behind (1) Middle-Earth (2) Harry Potter & (3) Thomas Covenant. All four are tremendous works in their own way, with different strengths & shortcomings.
Show this thread -
Narnia is more like the Potter books in terms of its reliance on children as protagonists. It's deeper & more Christian, but also less lively & cohesive as a unified piece of storytelling, shorter on its characters.
Show this thread -
Also, the Lion, the Witch, & the Wardrobe is (like the first Harry Potter & the Hobbit) more obviously a kids' book than the rest of the series. Voyage of the Dawn Treader is easily the best of the Narnia series.
Show this thread -
Confession: I didn't much like the Lion, the Witch, & the Wardrobe as a kid, never read the series until I tried with my son, gave up halfway thru Horse & His Boy. Only with my youngest did I get all the way through the series to appreciate the later books.
Show this thread -
The Hobbit, by contrast, was the first 'real' book I read, a a second-grader. Tolkien's world engrossed me throughout my youth.
Show this thread -
The two other big fantasy series I've read were Terry Brooks' Shannara series, which I read in my early teens and can no longer even remember at all, & Christopher Paolini's Eragon series, which I read aloud -- it was fun & had some great moments but was very derivative.
Show this thread -
Narrative challenge of Christian fantasy, which Tolkien & Lewis addressed in different ways: the reader wants the Hero to prevail, but this conflicts w/Christian lesson that victory comes only by humbling ourselves to accept salvation as a gift from God.https://twitter.com/MikeRathbone86/status/1254494219764408325 …
Show this thread -
They were sort of the Beatles & Stones of epic, highbrow fantasy writinghttps://twitter.com/barrelproven/status/1254493469449617409 …
Show this thread -
If you've never read the Covenant books, especially the original two trilogies, you should do that. Powerful & disturbing. Donaldson has a firm grip on fallibility & tragedy. And his vision of redemption is also ultimately quite Christian.
Show this thread -
As for the Paolini books, the ending (which I won't spoil here) is quite elegant; my favorite part is where the dragons band together to eliminate the names of their betrayers from their language, so they can no longer even *think* of their own selves.
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.