Lmao sorry to point it out but this is just the sort of textbook logical error that an anti-feminist would use against the claims of feminine/feminist "reason." (Excuse the scare quotes.)
Still, carry on. I like where you're going. Don't think an error can't be generative! 
-
-
-
I'm an amateur logician, yet I am not sure of the error here. Can you please point out the error?
-
Without looking it up, which would be boring, I think it's a misapplication of the disjunctive syllogism, which should look like this: A) People who know logic qualify as logicians. B) Sinistral knows logic. Therefore: C) Sinistral is a logician.
-
That's modus ponens though, isn't it? A disjunctive syllogism follows P ∨ Q, ¬P ⊢ Q Whereas, your argument seems to follow P → Q, P ⊢ Q (modus ponens) Also, "Rationalism itself must be a feminism" isn't meant to follow as a conclusion from "Xenofeminism is a rationalism."
-
Rather, "Rationalism itself must be a feminism" should be read in the imperative mode rather than declarative. "Must be" as in "ought to be" rather than "must be" as in "it is."
-
*imperative mood
-
Nice. Very nice. You clearly know your stuff. I think it was both the context ("rationalism") and the arrangement which made me think you were making a formally logical deduction in the original post. But my phone won't render the logic symbols in full, so... I cannot follow.
pic.twitter.com/hlWwWSupTC
-
Thanks! But I think I might've been mistaken about the argument form being modus ponens... rather, after going over it a second time, I think it's the close relative hypothetical syllogism. MP: P implies Q, P therefore Q HS: P implies Q, Q implies R, P therefore R I don't know.
- 1 more reply
New conversation -
-
-
is xenofeminism feminism for green girls?
-
for girls of all races and species
-
Anime girls aren't real and goth gf is a tool capitalists use to subsume the workers
- End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.