(The "discourse of the university" differs from the "discourse of the master" in that it is how someone exercises power while playing at powerlessness, in response to having genuinely been made powerless in other scenarios As Lacan would have it, to the extent I understand him)
-
Show this thread
-
(The whole cowardly "Hey, hey, I'M not taking any position, I'm just reporting on what the DATA says" shtick)
1 reply 6 retweets 156 likesShow this thread -
The response to "How can you prove that trans identity is valid, philosophically" is "How did cis people prove their identity was valid, philosophically" They didn't, of course, they just asserted their identity and did what they wanted
1 reply 60 retweets 278 likesShow this thread -
They set up a society in the first place and the academy just exists as this tangential offshoot of that society that inherited all of that society's baggage and, as the Joker would say, must by nature live in that society
1 reply 5 retweets 154 likesShow this thread -
As Lacan would put it (because he was, unfortunately, and ironically for this conversation, obsessed with people's balls) the discourse of the university is the discourse of the eunuch who seeks to find joy in his castration by castrating others
1 reply 8 retweets 138 likesShow this thread -
I.e. they neutered you (or, to get less gendery about it, neutralized you) by shunting you aside into this ivory tower where your thoughts and words wouldn't actually change anything, they convinced you your job was to describe the world and not to change it
1 reply 8 retweets 156 likesShow this thread -
And now you see your whole agenda as getting the rest of the world to just hold still so you can describe it better You think being neutralized makes you a smart erudite sophisticated civilized person and anyone who hasn't been neutralized comes off as a rude asshole to you
1 reply 11 retweets 166 likesShow this thread -
Everyone, of course, flipflops around between all four discourses based on their mood and their convenience It's fascinating to see TERFs locked in this mode -- "I just want to have a conversation, this is a big juicy philosophical problem" -- and then suddenly switch
1 reply 7 retweets 161 likesShow this thread -
Sometimes to the discourse of the analyst -- "Well, TRAs are very troubled people and I feel pity for them" -- but usually to the two most honest discourses, the discourse of the hysteric -- "I'm so TIRED and so ANGRY" -- and the master -- "You'll trans my kids OVER MY DEAD BODY"
2 replies 5 retweets 147 likesShow this thread -
See a lot of people accuse me of "dehumanizing" my ideological opponents and I don't think I'm doing that In fact I try to remember, always, that there's a human face of flesh and blood behind the discourse of the university ("The facts disagree with you sir") or the analyst
1 reply 4 retweets 150 likesShow this thread
(Someone tried to pull the latter on me just the other day -- "Who hurt you, Arthur? What demons are you running from that you have to tweet anger at strangers all the time?" -- and the answer, of course, is always 1) None of your business and 2) You're changing the subject)
-
-
The thing is, humans, unlike imaginary Rational Science Machines, are assholes They do shitty things for shitty stupid reasons that have nothing to do with you or with The Facts or any of that shit And you have to avoid letting them trick you into forgetting that
3 replies 35 retweets 227 likesShow this threadThanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.