It's just a huge pile of Wrong in one single Fun Fact from the Harry Potter-verse
-
Show this thread
-
Misremembering Madagascar as being in "West Africa" Confusing the Malagasy language with the divination practice of Sikidy Misspelling Sikidy "Sidiki" And then thinking one aspect of the sign was the sign's whole meaning
5 replies 78 retweets 1,357 likesShow this thread -
It's just... really fucking lazy and disrespectful It would not be a big deal -- it would be depressingly par for the course -- if it were just some random fantasy book But of course it's a big deal now because the books became a big deal And she never raised her standards
5 replies 52 retweets 1,304 likesShow this thread -
This is the same shitty level of research she put into bloviating about skinwalkers in Navajo culture or naga in Hindu culture Hell, it's the same shitty level of research she put into talking about boggarts and brownies and other elements of *English* culture
7 replies 86 retweets 1,408 likesShow this thread -
This is what I mean when I say she's not just a bad writer and a bigoted person but profoundly lazy Her worldview is shaped by this amazingly self-confident willingness to just glance at something once or twice and be sure she understands as much of it as she needs to
8 replies 177 retweets 1,781 likesShow this thread -
Was there ever any need to go back and look up what "Alohomora" meant? Nah Was there ever any worry that someone from the culture she was shamelessly lifting from might be offended or take issue with her? Nah Just plow on ahead, Jo, let your imagination be your compass
1 reply 45 retweets 1,137 likesShow this thread -
Go ahead and name that girl "Cho Chang" Who the fuck cares It sounds like a name to you and that's all that matters
30 replies 91 retweets 1,865 likesShow this thread -
Replying to @arthur_affect
You’ve apparently never met or known any kind of fiction author if you’re calling JKR lazy and ignorant based on this. Most fiction authors have nothing to do with history. They are making. Stuff. Up. And you just called her an idiot for naming a magical spell something.
4 replies 0 retweets 0 likes -
Replying to @Anonversations
If you've never read a fiction author who shows more passion and depth in how they handle real world cultures in their writing than JK Rowling then you have been sorely deprived
6 replies 5 retweets 123 likes -
Replying to @arthur_affect
JK Rowling doesn’t handle real world cultures in her fantasy series. That you’re doing forensic exegesis of her writing style is the sad part here.
3 replies 0 retweets 1 like
It's not really that "forensic" to ask what the word "Alohomora" means This is what's honestly sinister about the whole way this topic gets discussed - Malagasy culture is a real thing that exists in the real world, it's not some body of archeological trivia
-
-
Replying to @arthur_affect @Anonversations
It's a generally shitty thing white writers do to treat real life cultures they consider foreign as just bodies of "lore" for them to mine and then to remix and recontextualize as they see fit, as though other countries are just fairytale kingdoms from children's stories
4 replies 22 retweets 113 likes -
Replying to @arthur_affect @Anonversations
And JK Rowling does this A LOT, which is why she gets people so pissed at her Like she thought it'd be clever to do a good-guy-bad-guy switch with Navajo skinwalkers and say skinwalkers were really innocent Animagi who were persecuted by evil charlatans
1 reply 6 retweets 65 likes - Show replies
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.