Except that she, also, threatens to murder a defenseless teenager - WHO SAVED HER WIFE'S LIFE previously
-
-
And that question can't be answered without answering all the other questions raised by TLoU 1 If dissecting Ellie is a justifiable and necessary act then the Fireflies were, in fact, innocent and Joel's massacre is an act of murder He started it
-
If it's unjustifiable no matter what in your view, then yes, everyone at the hospital is a murderer or an accessory, Joel was heroically trying to save his daughter, and Abby is the one who fires the first shot in the exchange by killing an innocent man for no good reason
- Show replies
New conversation -
-
-
I mean I think even if I believed Joel was wrong I would believe Abby also had one of the weakest cases of anyone to go that hard in her revenge, given that she was avenging someone who was de facto a combatant(carries a rifle normally) and about to kill someone EVEN IF JUSTIFIED
-
It would feel less justified but probably be easier to justify philosophically if it were really the whole world she were avenging, if she just felt very strongly that a vaccine would've worked, rather than it being "personal" in this sense
- Show replies
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.