It's not necessarily that weird a take, like the Bible repeatedly describes believing in and worshiping God as "fearing God" I've talked directly to an Orthodox Jewish person who said in his personal opinion using the word "good" for G-d in the modern sense is misleading https://twitter.com/UnknownEnby/status/1255031053204377605 …
-
-
There's this whole list of rules and agreements built up around entities much greater and more powerful than us puny individuals, entities that kind of adhere to human values but are so much bigger than us they're inescapably alien Beings like corporations, estates, governments
Show this thread -
(Of course those beings don't exist in any physical sense, they're just invented by humans, they're "made of" humans, and every action they take is ultimately an action of some individual human who just believes they're acting on its behalf Hot take -- so are gods)
Show this thread -
And the whole thing about being a lawyer is the whole job requires you have a sense of "is" and "ought" separately in your head
Show this thread -
The stereotype that to be a lawyer is to be totally amoral is wrong -- in fact if you didn't have ANY idea of "ought" you couldn't be a lawyer, every lawyer who practices law is fighting in some small way for a worldview, even one they don't actually admit they hold
Show this thread -
But the whole point of your job, what your job actually is, is to work within the "is" of the status quo You tell your client what will *actually happen* if they run a red light, or if they illegally download The Last of Us 2, or if they allow Russia to interfere in an election
Show this thread -
Like in my limited experience a big big part of the job -- the point of being a lawyer, the reason everyone tells you "talk to a lawyer before you do X" -- is to try to readjust a client's expectations between how things *should* work and what actually happens when you do things
Show this thread -
That "lawyering" mindset is very much there in religion, especially Abrahamic religion, rooted in the so-called "ancient Near East covenant" model The Ten Commandments are a contract God makes with Moses as the representative of his people
Show this thread -
The other stuff is there -- a personal emotional relationship with God as parent or lover or object of devotion But the core is the Law "These are the rules, this is how it works, this is the procedure by which we exchange sacrifice and worship for safety and prosperity"
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
I LOVE this idea. Even outside of dnd, even a super normal world where the only difference is ::guestures to your ideA:: this.
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
-
-
I'm suddenly reminded of the line from Pratchett where he said that sometimes the gods would come around to atheists' houses and break their windows.
-
Yeah exactly Being a D&D/Discworld atheist is like being an anarchist in our world I may very well not think that the gods *should* be gods and I may not recognize their authority in a moral sense and I may deeply hate them But I pay my taxes so I don't go to jail
- Show replies
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.