Was studying a vocal arrangement to get how its harmony works, felt like I was following, then—bam! Are there good frameworks for understanding tone clusters like these? Like: why every diatonic *except* G# on the first cluster? Should we see the second as an elaborate V of ii?
Conversation
(from this remarkable arrangement of Bon Iver's 715 - CRΣΣKS: youtu.be/tffl66nJPWY?t=; see discussion from arranger here: youtu.be/G4u84zaAHPk?t=)
1
1
3
Honestly (just on piano here), the first tone cluster doesn't seem that different with vs without the G#. Maybe it was just that they ran out of voices—only had ~10 singers for those 7 notes and the arranger wanted more people on the melody, F#->E.
Replying to
Oh, OK, the arranger sort of answers me! This description suggests he sees the second cluster as a second inversion E9 (i.e. inverting the first chord of that measure), plus "anguish." (heh)
1
3