Steven Pinker's new book, "Rationality", was just released. My impression, 1/4 through, is that it could use a strong dose of "meta-/post-rat" (whatever that means)!
e.g. how do we deal with the nebulosity of "vegetable"? neural nets and weights! sure, in some sense, but…
Conversation
Pleased to see that the book includes quite a concise but clear explainer of causal networks.
1
12
I guess it gets worse.
Quote Tweet
Black person: gets mortgage denied
Pinker: well, was it really racism? or was it simply because the US government, banks, real estate agents and millions of Americans engaged in a multi-decade project of segregation and disinvestment?
Show this thread
1
Honestly, that section of the book was quite sensitively handled. The whole point of it was to underscore how challenging it is to use data without introducing unexpected problems. I don't think the Times's characterization is just.
1
Rather, I don't think the second sentence in the excerpt is just. The first sentence ("blinkered") is perhaps not unreasonable: it's a bit odd to discuss these tensions in the abstract, without at any point referencing the concrete historical instances of redlining.
Show more replies