Conversation

Vlad Sitalo
@VladyslavSitalo
I'm curious if anyone managed to make
@hypothes_is
work well for "stacked" digital gardens (like
@andy_matuschak
notes). twitter.com/houshuang/stat
@houshuang
@karlicoss
have you had any luck?
Quote Tweet
Stian Håklev
@houshuang
·
Replying to @houshuang @karlicoss and @hypothes_is
BTW Wondering how Hypothes.is will work with the new style of multi-panel blogs, like Andy's notes - if you annotate the second panel, it won't be properly linked because the URL is misleading. Any way of indicating the proper URL here in the HTML @hypothes_is ?
Image
2
1
3
Vlad Sitalo
@VladyslavSitalo
So when you leave annotations in one view - they end up being displayed as orphans unless you construct exactly the same URL as when you created the annotations =\
2
Dan Whaley
@dwhly
@WardCunningham
showed me a similar situation on
@fedwiki
there. There though as they move through successive panels the URL *does* change iirc. If the URL isn’t changing then it is technically the same page. The only solution is something interactive, like an SPA?
2
2
Dan Whaley
@dwhly
Ah, but the problem w/ stacked pages is that the URL is dependent on the collection as stacked. It’s not a unique URL per object, it’s … a stack of objects. An idea I discussed w/ Ward was to ensure that each page had canonical URL in metadata.
2
1
Stian Håklev
@houshuang
I was trying to figure this out a while back, and I imagined that there could be a <data-canonical-url> or something that, that would indicate that all the child content belongs to that "virtual page". Not sure if you can use a selector to find "ancestor data tag"?
2
2
Stian Håklev
@houshuang
Another use case is "river of news" pages, like a blog that has all full-text posts on the same page, but what exactly you see on a given URL depends on the date, pagination etc.
1
1
1