An unintuitive secret of reading books on computers: reading PDFs with original typesetting is much better than reading ebooks, which treat text like a 4chan shitposter and have impoverished reading software.
But… where to get the PDFs?! A survey & suggestions for future work:
Conversation
Google Play:
👍 ~smooth workflow; clean pages
👎 PDFs lack text layer, so they're not searchable or selectable; only recent books available in PDF
archive.org:
👍 has many older books Play lacks; includes OCR'd text layer
👎 OCR errors; photo noise; clunkier workflow
1
3
25
Z-Library:
👍 occasionally has clean PDFs for books which others lack
👎 PDFs are often EPUB->PDF conversions (the worst!); more illegal
4
1
23
One fun project idea: maybe you could improve upon the poor text layers in Play / archive.org's PDFs by building a tool which combines EPUBs and PDFs by aligning the EPUB's original text onto the PDF pages via OCR.
1
4
22
Maybe you could improve the EPUB reading experience by extracting text block layout parameters from the PDFs through computer vision: ie. try to estimate the text block width/height, line height, and font size in the original typesetting. Similar technique could map page numbers.
3
16
Related: while e-book reading software are truly impoverished, PDF software is also almost universally unimaginative and unserious for the task of reading. Would love to see more work there…
Replying to
Don't you think that until the authors start caring about how their books look and work as ebooks, things are unlikely to change?
1
Probably true. I suspect many do care, though that doesn't mean they feel they can do anything about it. Typesetting is usually in the publisher's hands.
Replying to
On iOS/iPadOS 's PDF Expert has a relatively new "reading mode" which kind of resembles the reading experience of the kindle/Apple books app.
You don't have access to essential tools like highlighting or annotating text in it yet though, which is quite a bummer.
1
2
2
Maybe they also work on a dedicated reading mode for the desktop app.
As you said, there's great potential there.
Replying to
I have enjoyed using for papers on my iPad lately; it's basically a technology showcase for
1
2
Thanks Scott! We’re on macOS too - still a lot to do with the Catalyst upgrades!
1
Show replies
Replying to
Hi Andy, check out what we’ve done with reading mode in our @PDFExpert7 m.pdfexpert.com/blog/reading-m
1
1