One way to look at memory systems' efficiency is marginal cost: I can choose to "pay" 5m over my lifetime to memorize the answer to a question. I find it generative to flip that around. Say I saturated 10 minutes of review daily—what would that casual practice unlock? (thread)
-
-
There's some tension here. If I made my own 112 prompts for the first chapter of QC, I'd likely get a much deeper understanding of the material. But—also—I probably wouldn't do it! I want to spend that effort on material core to my creative work, less on more peripheral material.
Show this thread -
The first chapter of QC takes most readers 4 hours to read (and has 112 questions). I spend 1-2 hours a day reading. So if the mnemonic medium were ubiquitous, I'd end up adding 40 questions a day, no sweat. That seems awfully enticing!
Show this thread -
The mnemonic medium is a long way from ubiquity, to put it mildly. In the meantime, I've significantly increased my rate of new SRS prompts with another approach: turning my daily writing practice into a kind of *personal* mnemonic medium.
Show this thread -
I write for a few hours each day, accumulating notes like the ones you see in this thread. They really help me think. https://notes.andymatuschak.org/zVFGpprS64TzmKGNzGxq9FiCDnAnCPwRU5T … But as I write prose about those topics, I also write SRS questions inline, much like the mnemonic medium.https://notes.andymatuschak.org/z5ARNXtS5VxteskEW91S1yYTgAcLABNXsZuJE …
Show this thread -
Those embedded questions end up in my daily review practice. I find that it's easier to write a lot of them this way, in the context of writing prose. Particularly cloze deletions. The practice feels quite strange! It certainly distorts the prose… but not always harmfully?
Show this thread -
One thing I like about this approach is: I don't want to just remember things I read—I want SRS to help me develop new ideas! I want to regularly review all the fragmentary inklings I sketch on the way to new insights. Embedded prompts are a convenient way to make that happen.
Show this thread -
I feel I don't yet understand the personal mnemonic medium at all: I've only been writing this style of note for about a month. It's different from the mnemonic medium, and it's different from my old note medium, which is itself idiosyncratically different from normal notes.
Show this thread -
I do notice that my 40 question/day quota is more consistently saturated with this practice, and that may be the high-order bit! And of course, if review sessions are sufficiently valuable, that cap will grow: people will happily spend more than 10 minutes per day.
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
I’m not sure if you agree but I’ve found that evergreen notes are actually quite transferable, or at least an excellent starting point for integrating into one’s own collection. It the problem with sharing SRS prompts is that they lack context then this makes perfect sense.
-
Alas, I don't know enough people who both write and regularly share these to know. I hope that'll change.
- 1 more reply
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.