countertheory: rational problem solving is one aspect of cognition that is emphasized in species or individuals when there's pressure for it
Conversation
Replying to
yes, exactly. it's only something that is optimized for when it's necessary. *when optimized for*, it does not require much computation mass
1
6
further hypothesis: imagine a human-like intelligence specifically designed to not have infrastructure for maintaining/using a body
1
6
e.g. EVE Online pod pilot, etc. someone who can think and communicate, but does not need to use arms.
1
7
i would hypothesize that you could make such a brain 10x smaller without making that person less intelligent.
3
9
that is, most of our brain is effectively coprocessors for managing a wide variety of things, and most of those are body-related.
2
1
9
Replying to
hmm tool use? cats are physically unable to make diverse tools (if they use any at all), so no need for fine motor control
2
3
there's a semi-prominent theory that most "smart" stuff is basically an outgrowth of being able to hit things with thrown objects
1
6
you have to plan the motion in advance, and suchlike
2
2
huh wait isn't throwing stuff the archetypical "embodied cognition" task? aka the kind of cognition that relies on very little planning
1
ok wait the archetypical task was catching stuff - throwing stuff is another one though (lots of reading here: psychsciencenotes.blogspot.de/p/the-rough-gu)
embodied cognition would be pretty crap if it excluded planning entirely
1
2
but by planning i meant that throwing happens fast enough that you can't make a lot of adjustments to muscle movements while it happens
1
1
Show replies



