I think D&G do a great analysis of errors of abstraction when they talk of statements both too abstract and not abstract enough.
Conversation
Replying to
Ahh. Well I don't see how abstraction errors are limited to democracy, plenty of mismanagement by monarchies.
1
Replying to
Failed megaprojects are great examples of the kind of abstraction error a monarchy likes to commit.
2
Replying to
Democracy is like a monarchy except with a hated and impotent monarch who gets replaced with another.
1
Replying to
sorry to rehash an old argument from elsewhere, but being voted out of office surely beats a war of succession?
1
Replying to
I do see monarchies being better at long-term coherence, as long as the same monarch lives.
1
Replying to
The choice of successor should of course be up to the monarch. It need not be primogeniture.
1
1
Replying to
But let's say I choose from my courtiers. The selection pressure at my court will be brutal and select for the wrong things.
2
Replying to
All that before I can even make a choice, and it has to be well informed by... well probably my intelligence service.
3
Replying to
I think the choice would come down to a small group of nobles directly in the kings service. No mediation required.
1
Replying to
Choosing from your nobles ends in heredity (eventually one will appoint their own bloodline).
Replying to
That is a speculation based on the inescapable corruption of all men, with that thinking we are doomed to fail.
Replying to
it might be inevitable given a highly clannish culture but outbred NW Europeans? It's at least not easily fated.
1
Show replies