Controversies and court cases had plagued the Hawaiian Homes program for years. Created by a federal law a century ago, there are only 10k current homesteaders, while the waitlist has grown to nearly 29k.
-
-
Show this thread
-
Our reporting uncovered previously unknown ways the program had fallen short. The overarching theme of it all was that low income Hawaiians were unable to reclaim their ancestral lands because of the way the program had been administered in recent decades.
Show this thread -
The federal law that created the program made no mention of how rich Hawaiians had to be to receive a homestead lease. But because of a variety of factors, there’s a de facto barrier to entry: can you afford a $200k or $300k mortgage?
Show this thread -
The state chose to focus on master-planned subdivisions in recent decades. Their rationale was that it would help produce more homes more quickly for a waitlist that was expanding at an alarming rate.
Show this thread -
For those who could afford it, the homesteads could be a great deal. You’d pay roughly half what you would pay for a home off trust land. But, as the department soon found out, it simply wasn’t an option for lower income folks near the top of the waitlist.
Show this thread -
That’s where the data came in. Using the state Department of Hawaiian Home Lands internal databases, we were able to see what the effect of these practices were.https://www.propublica.org/article/draft-hawaii-homesteads-mainbar …
Show this thread -
We found 60% of residential homestead leases awarded on Oahu in the past 25 years went to Census tracts with median household incomes greater than $75,000.
Show this thread -
The department would often have to go thousands deep on its waitlist to find people willing and able to accept a lease and the mortgage that came with it.
Show this thread -
Meanwhile, we found more than 2k people who had died on the waitlist without ever receiving a homestead lease. That’s almost certainly an undercount because the department only records the death of a waitlister when they receive a death certificate, usually from a family member.
Show this thread -
And the initial motivation of the subdivision strategy -- to build more homes to move people off the waitlist most quickly -- hasn’t worked out either.
Show this thread -
It would take the department an additional 182 years to provide everyone on the waitlist with a residential lot, based on its rate of production in the past 25 years.pic.twitter.com/XtDkOtztxx
Show this thread -
And in recent years, following budget constraints, the department has struggled to produce homesteads. In three of the past five years, awards actually fell into the single digits.pic.twitter.com/bmT6s2D7Yx
Show this thread -
The department says the subdivision model was meant to appease the top choice of waitlisters: single-family homes. And it says it’s working more affordable options into its offerings. The main constraint: funding.
Show this thread -
Read more about how we analyzed the department’s data to uncover these findings here.https://www.propublica.org/article/how-we-found-low-income-hawaiians-were-left-behind-by-the-homesteading-program …
Show this thread -
This project was part of
@ProPublica’s Local Reporting Network and is a great example of the amazing work we can do with the local newsrooms. Special thanks to Rob for his incredible work on this project and for being a great collaborator &@mjmishak for his editsShow this thread -
Stay tuned folks, plenty more to come!
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.