🐈

the central state does not actually have any excess of “stuff” with which to “bailout” anyone. it has infinite money in theory, but that is not “stuff”, it just indirectly encourages and discourages certain behaviors

so asking it for a “bailout” like it was a Rich Dad does not work. it just forces it into a position as intermediary to ask the people who do have stuff to do some redistributing

imagine going through an intermediary when having a fight with a colleague or a friend. has that ever worked? now add in an element of begging for “free” stuff

the only excess of stuff that the central state DOES have is is a surplus of violence via the military. when the state is expected to shoulder more and more responsibility instead of delegating to individuals it either needs to seize the production or start a war

every state that has tried to forcibly create a transfer of wealth just alienates individuals and causes capital flight. like when all the best people start leaving in a company and the worse people start filling in to the senior and management roles. it’s an irreversible decline

every state that has seized production also has managed it into the ground. even a state like china does not directly manage its state companies but forces it to self police and conform to certain political expectations while leaving alone the actual production decisions

another issue is that the wealthy also don’t have that much “stuff”. just like the government, they just have surplus of paper wealth that cannot be directly used for anything except motivating certain behaviors

a trillionaire does not actually have a trillion dollars of “stuff” to give out. the wealth is just an accounting of “ownership” over patterns of activity in the economy