Yasmine Mohammed ياسمين محمد  🦋

similar incident report from Australia also amazing, many people use the argument as the fastest growing religion to say its a great one @alibil

Islam has 1.7b in its fold, with 72 recognised sects, varied customs spread across the globe. It's not some paltry outfit in some corner of the world. An Indian Muslim has more in common with Indians of other faiths then an Algerian Muslim & this incident is purely culture-based

How can you say it's just cultural when the texts clearly state the death penalty for apostates?

Have u realized which text he quoted? They're Hadiths, not the Holy Quran. Hadiths r a collection of incidents/sayings that were accumulated, more than 200 odd years after the advent of Islam. The compiler himself has said that he rejected 90% of the narrations he received in...

.. his arduous mission of traveling places & collecting them. Although he tried his best, but it's not the word of God. You have Sahih(accurate), Hasan(good), Da'if(weak) hadiths. If the Hadith tallies with the Quran's philosophy, it should be accurate. Otherwise, it's not a...

There's no Mahdi in the Quran, no details on prayer, no mention of prescribed slaughter for meat. Who gets to decide which Hadith adds true details, and which are "innovations"? Men? Sounds like the process that corrupted all religions in the past.

Well, I feel that's where the Muslim ummah is lost, in rules. The forget the essence, the message, just follow rules,for instance. Plz think it over & tell me, what are we actually doing when we pray our daily namaz?

Perhaps you want Islam to be a better religion than it ever really was. Harsh rules have been fundamental to Islam since its birth. As an ex-Muslims, I would say these rituals serve the purpose of brainwashing. Breaking us away from reality and keeping us devout to the fiction.