Scotch

Sylv doing what ever it takes is not out of character,not sure where people get that from.Sylv doing dumb things like walking away from the kill of malfurion and burning the tree rather then keeping the hostages,that's where the questions are raised.Plot ofc, but plot can be bett

Sylvanas ordered her top general - one of only 2 people she trusted with the real Dark shore invasion plan - to kill a prone Malfurion. I don't think that's unreasonable or stupid personally.

I think it is when you know someone like Saurfang is all about that honor and killing Malfurion was apperantly such a key to your plans, you had to burn down a tree and turn everyone against you to fix it.

Well you say that Nobs but he had JUST stabbed Malfy in the back with his axe. I can see why Sylvanas could assume he was on-side at that moment.

He did and then he blabbered on about how 'dishonorable' it was... I mean...sure we need malf to keep on kicking but from Sylvs pov, too just walk away? And write it off as over confidence...Come onnnn

Anyone considered these are tests, to test the resolve of her soldiers. Remember, Vol'jin still made her warchief with the promise that she will save us all.

I mean, the CE knocks out any sort of test as reasoning + testing your soldiers at such a critical moment of your plan...She was so close to fullfilling it. All she had to do was one shot and BAM VICTORY...

Victory... assuming killing Malfurion HAD actually worked as intended to kill the NE hope. Which it may not of. It's a pretty big assumption.