I am not saying "don't listen to doctors", I'm saying "use your own reasoning skills". If they don't have em'... no help for them anywhere.
Conversation
Replying to
Yeah, I mean that's what I'm getting at - I suspect most people's reasoning skills are no match for their doctor's knowledge.
5
Replying to
IMO: seek help for acute illness or anything that makes you scared, but steer clear otherwise, unless you know your doctor is the real deal.
1
Replying to
You list 100 symptoms, they made a conclusion at nr. 5. You list 2, they start asking questions and eliminating options - if they any good.
1
Replying to
The doctor should be doing this stuff - are you saying that you think doctors are worse than average at evaluating symptoms?
2
Replying to
If your doctor doesn't know a positive on a test is 90% likely to be a false positive, that's a bit problematic (they usually don't).
1
Replying to
I suspect your advice works for science-minded, intelligent and fairly knowledgeable people - often.
1
But the people refusing vaccines because of stuff they've read on the Internet typically fall into that category.
4
Which makes me wonder if it works work for common ailments and other medical problems. Doctors *should* be at a huge advantage.
2
1
Replying to
Doctors are taught to solve problems in a medical context. The problem is the advice people need is often "eat less cake", "sleep more" etc.