TBH, I'm going to be reflexively cautious about anyone who claims authority, rather than providing cogent moral ideas.
Conversation
Replying to
I don't listen to everything a doctor says just because they are a medical authority, either... need reasons.
Same for any other field.
1
Replying to
Yeah, I think that's the proven with NdGT etc - there's at least an implied "because science" tagged on what he says.
2
Replying to
I wouldn't waltz into a lab or emergency room to tell them what to do, but when the cigarette-smoking doctor tells me to eat this or that...
1
1
Replying to
To be fair, in that case they are sticking to their field and the parameters are fairly clearly set. Most people probably benefit.
2
Replying to
Do they? We have a huge mental health epidemic b/c doctors get paid by big pharma to push psychiatric drugs for every problem...
1
1
Replying to
I think the majority work with the tools they have, often get it wrong but usually help people.
3
I'm sure there's corruption in some places and maybe I'm just super lucky to have the NHS, but I think doctors help on average.
4
Replying to
Even then, if the competent doctor makes a proclamation that seems very strange, we'd be likely to seek a second opinion. Error is the norm.
1
Replying to
Sure and managing your own health is sensible, but some people will be using their own ideas to avoid vaccines, use homeopathy, etc (..?)
1
Replying to
I am not saying "don't listen to doctors", I'm saying "use your own reasoning skills". If they don't have em'... no help for them anywhere.
Replying to
Yeah, I mean that's what I'm getting at - I suspect most people's reasoning skills are no match for their doctor's knowledge.
5
Replying to
Short of an acute emergency, those people are precisely those who benefit the least from going to a doctor. They end up on terrible meds.