Because when you reach this level of refinement in any skill, *thinking* about it actually represses your abilities.
Conversation
Replying to
Your advancement is contingent precisely on learning so many fruitful habits of action that it takes no thought to execute your skill.
1
Replying to
When you start thinking about it, you find your skill lowers to the level of the cognitive or associative stage. Deliberate and very clumsy.
1
Replying to
I've practiced enough meditation that for me, thinking about meditating makes me... not meditate. This is the key insight of Zen practice.
1
Replying to
But to get to the level where this even makes sense talking about, you do have to practice - slowly and deliberately.
1
Replying to
In every area where skill can be cultivated, people frequently fall into the trap of trying to imitate adepts before they practice anything.
1
Replying to
This is always a giant waste of time, and incredibly frustrating to attempt (been there, done that). You lack the necessary fundamentals.
1
Replying to
So if you're just getting into meditation, and your practice is not yet at the stage where you can just tune out freely... do make an effort
1
1
Replying to
Whereas if you've been practicing for a long time and still can't get that gibbering voice in your head to calm down... try relaxing.
1
Replying to
Try to meditate while doing something else. Just say to yourself "I'm meditating now," and let it do its thing.
1
Replying to
I stopped *trying* to meditate this week and discovered that I do it far better with 0 effort than any amount of trying would accomplish..
Replying to
Oh and you can still sit or lie down in silence, but the key thing is understanding that *trying* to meditate will have the same effect as-
1
1
Replying to
- *trying* to ride a bike when you're a veteran cyclist, or, to take an example everyone can grasp, *trying* to walk.
1
Show replies
