This is important because several traditions, esp. in an impoverished western view, seem to hinge on meditation not being about skill...
Conversation
Replying to
Notions such as "effortless attention," "not trying to meditate," etc. gets thrown around a lot, particularly by Western Zen evangelists.
1
1
Replying to
These notions aren't wrong, but it's important to understand that they describe something closer to the pinnacle of accomplishment...
1
Replying to
... which, to your layman's ears, is exactly what Zen says isn't there.. This is a linguistic trick that means smth else, however.
1
Replying to
And while the usage in Zen is actually correct, it's easily misunderstood. So too for many other traditions, esp. Buddhist traditions.
1
Replying to
Let's return to the idea of meditation-as-a-skill. You may know the idea that skill acquisition works in stages. In basic terms...
1
Replying to
... we start out thinking a lot about how to do something (kick a ball, sing a verse...) and doing it in a very clumsy, mechanical manner.
1
Replying to
This gradually moves into a phase where practice is effortful, but more fluid and less error-prone.
1
Replying to
Eventually, you arrive at a stage where the skill can be applied autonomously. You can think, in some cases even talk, while doing it.
1
Replying to
This theory may have holes or flaws, but you can see how it relates to Zen and disciplines stressing effortless practice.
1
Replying to
Effortless practice is a level you get to after lots of effortful, often harrowing practice. But when you get there, it's the only way to go
Replying to
Because when you reach this level of refinement in any skill, *thinking* about it actually represses your abilities.
1
Replying to
Your advancement is contingent precisely on learning so many fruitful habits of action that it takes no thought to execute your skill.
1
Show replies