Conversation

Replying to

mindfulness can be a great discipline & foundation for other work. but orgs who fetishize it as a main practice, especially w/t regard for the fact that people experience it differently depending on things like trauma history, JUST might be keeping you frozen.

Caroline

@spacecrone

Jul 8, 2019

mindfulness is a completely unregulated industry at this point, and i reject the idea that it is a student's fault for not vetting a teacher enough, especially when teacher bios can be cobbled together from absolute nonsense that will never get verified

Replying to

and

You really want a bunch of bureaucrats and insurance companies to "regulate" your scene, tho?

Replying to

and

is that the only other option you can think of? lots of communities have mechanisms of accountability and self-regulation.

Replying to

and

*phew* I thought you were going somewhere real dark

Replying to

and

i have seen attempts to regulate mindfulness instruction in that way and they are a nightmare!

Replying to

and

Yeah. It's a mess on every end. I usually hate "cultural appropriation" as a term, but Mindfulness(tm) really is theft. And not only do you have legit unqualified, inexperienced people teaching this stuff, but the actual traditions are far too esoteric for normies to evaluate.

Replying to

and

it becomes the worst kind of context-free advice, where various levels of practice are collapsed into aphorisms

Replying to

and

Right? Every solely mindfulness-oriented practitioner I've talked to who was any good has run into Serious Shit that no weekend coach could help with. "You're seeing what in this room? You have completely overwhelming outbursts of which emotions? You're -depersonalizing-???"

Replying to

and

i didn't really realize how potentially dangerous that was (as someone who was taught 'it's not like you're going to break anyone's brain' in teacher training) until I took a trauma-informed yoga teacher training and was like, ohhhh, this is not at all how I learned to guide ppl