Summing up: the President of my professional organization used his monthly column to give us a half-assed, poorly-written, evidence-challenged screed that justifiably pissed off a wide swath of the membership. The essay's original tweet got ratioed into oblivion (1/x)
Conversation
2/ Then, after what I can only presume was an avalanche of responses pointing out his misogynoir, condescending tone, lack of actual evidence, and the profound offense he gave to BIPOC scholars among others, he issued a superficially OK but substance-free apology.
read image description
ALT
4
17
292
4/ And now, the rock is kicked over and all the usual Right Wing trolls and academic crank jobs are painting Sweet's back-of-the-barroom-napkin ramblings as the avatar of brave truth-telling, and the AHA is today's Main Character on Twitter.
read image description
ALT
3
13
341
5/ Either Sweet didn't know, or he didn't care, about the entirely predictable outcome of his actions. I can't decide which is worse. My brother in christ, YOU ARE THE PRESIDENT OF THE AMERICAN FREAKING HISTORICAL ASSOCIATION. DO BETTER.
1
30
538
6/Richard Goddamn Spencer is defending Sweet as the last true Rankean, FFS. The AHA has had to lock down its Twitter account because the replies to Sweet's apology are filled with Roman-sculpture avatars and "classical liberals" screaming about SURRENDERING TO WOKEISM HURR DURRRR
5
33
392
7/ Once Sweet clicked "publish" on his freshman essay masquerading as a presidential column, it was never not going to end up here.
3
15
343
8/ Anyway, maybe it's time (as has suggested) to stop passing the AHA presidency around a tight little circle of senior faculty at elite institutions like it's the member of the month award at the Elks Lodge.
5
45
643
9/ (If you think my characterization of Sweet's essay is unfair, I explain my reasoning here: thetattooedprof.com/2022/08/19/on-.) /End thread
16
45
357
Seems like "listening and learning" has taken off as a side meme as well?
3
37
Apparently. Just great work all around from my discipline's leadership
4
40
Show replies

