A Moogle  🏳️‍🌈 💻 🎮 🎶 🇸🇪

That seems unlikely to yield noticeably better results than just playing the disk on a high-quality player and capturing the composite video output. (Unlike video tape "color under", Laserdisc directly records composite video. No benefit to s-video output.)

It's not a matter of results being *visibly* better. It's that if a player has a good/no-good signal from the pickup for any given sample read off the disc, the data can be *provably good*, and a known-to-be-perfect dump can be merged from reads off multiple discs.

By way of analogy: Your argument is that a dump of a bit-rotted graphics ROM IC from an arcade board is just as good as a non-bit-rotted dump, if the affected bits don't visibly affect the graphics shown in-game. I won't sugar-coat it, that's not preservation, that's half-assing.

Not only that, capturing the visible video with a capture card doesn't capture the data contained in the vertical blanking region, where many LD arcade titles store data used by the games. Even worse, the digital data stored in some audio tracks can get mangled.

The LD players used in the games don't allow any application data to be stored in the blanking interval. The blanking interval is used internally for player control, and is not externally accessible even on the OEM players.

This is hilariously wrong and I would appreciate it if @aaronsgiles could give me an assist here considering as he was involved in dumping what LD games are currently supported by MAME.

Correction, it's partially correct, but only partially. http://aarongiles.com/?p=238  More info than just the frame index is stored in the VBI region. And considering as the VBI region is an inherent part of the video signal, the video signal should be captured together with the disc.

If you don't feel that it's worthwhile to try to capture laserdiscs with as high accuracy as possible, then you're more than entitled to your opinion. And I appreciate your help with the LCD games. But respectfully, if you want to tell me how to spend my time, get bent.