Opens profile photo
Follow
Sunetra Gupta
@SunetraGupta
Joined October 2014

Sunetra Gupta’s Tweets

Thank you for picking out the perfect summary of my position
Quote Tweet
"We inverted precautionary principle of trying to minimize harm by doing the one thing that we knew would cause harm: lockdowns.. What we do see very sadly.. harms unfolded.. We sit watching devastation that we knew these measures would cause 2yrs ago” —Oxford Prof @SunetraGupta
Embedded video
2:06
76
5,044
This could never have been anticipated but we must still all in the biomedical community take responsibility for this, even those who warned against vaccinating individuals who were very unlikely to develop life-threatening symptoms upon infection,
Quote Tweet
Replying to @VPrasadMDMPH
Damage to vax programs will be horrific in decades to come. This administration has made major errors. It pushed too hard on the wrong ages, wrong risk groups; It demanded too little evidence from Pfizer. When necessary childhood vaccine programs collapse, they will be to blame
148
1,291
Thank you, Allison, for your support and let’s hope 2022 is a better year for all of us
Quote Tweet
We salute the great @MartinKulldorff @DrJBhattacharya and @SunetraGupta who never foreswore the principles of epidemiology to fall in line with a cowardly and hysterical anti-scientific consensus. History will restore them to their rightful place. twitter.com/MartinKulldorf…
39
1,108
Models are wonderful conceptual tools, but should never be used to make predictions in the face of high uncertainty nature.com/articles/35088 We need strategies - like Focused Protection - that are robust to uncertainty, rather than unreliable predictions.
Quote Tweet
1/- The problem with epidemiological modelling The discussion of their meaning reflects 1. Unexpected centrality of these models in policy formation. 2. Lack of serious discussion (including by modellers) of their philosophy. [nice short piece here} ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/P
Image
32
882
Finally breaking my twitter silence with this:
Quote Tweet
Fundamental principles of epidemic spread highlight the immediate need for large-scale serological surveys to assess the stage of the SARS-CoV-2 epidemic (soon to be on medRxiv) @SunetraGupta dropbox.com/s/oxmu2rwsnhi9
Image
107
499
So disappointing to have to battle this out in the media rather than through a phonecall, Danny, but here are some explainers on what herd immunity actually means and how it is independent of the rate of loss of immunity collateralglobal.org/article/how-se collateralglobal.org/article/mini-l
Quote Tweet
In which an immunologist at Imperial College London discovers that a virus that brings only short-term immunity, and for which we have only a non-sterilising vaccine, cannot be eliminated. theguardian.com/commentisfree/
20
486
I am deeply saddened and disappointed in your characterisation of the GBD although I know you mean well, Francois
Quote Tweet
This is naive, Prof. Balloux. You are protecting your good nature on powerful lockdowners like Fauci, Collins, and Farrar, who by Oct. 2020 had already caused devastating harm. In their hubris, they would never have compromised, as that would have meant admitting error. [1/2] twitter.com/BallouxFrancoi…
23
370
Thank you, James, for adding substantially to our analyses and for getting the message across far more clearly than us - as Jose has already said.
Quote Tweet
A recent analysis from Oxford presented a range of model scenarios consistent with observed COVID death counts. I’m going to reproduce their analysis here and then present some slight modifications to provide a conservative (if technical) perspective. (gonna be 15ish tweets)
89
284
Thank you to Freddie and the rest of the UnHerd crew for scrupulously seeking to present every side of this debate right from the start
Quote Tweet
In 2020, Prof @SunetraGupta was pilloried for her suggestion to @UnHerd that the Covid Infection Fatality Rate could be close to 5 in 10,000. Three years on, new data from Denmark suggests the real figure is... 6.5 in 10,000. Read her response here: unherd.com/thepost/how-wr
21
326
“We are all responsible for this…as well as not being directly to blame”
Quote Tweet
Before I exposed ambulance delay cover up in my dad’s death I was told by a senior NHS cardiologist not to as it ‘would make me enemies’ I ignored his advice because ‘Those who do nothing are inviting shame. Those who act boldly are recognising right as well as reality’ JFK
Embedded video
2:19
13
296
I agree with everything that you say and my opinion, for what it’s worth, is this was not a lab leak – but how can you say you uphold these principles when you have repeatedly vilified me and others for suggesting that lockdowns were not the most humane solution to this crisis?
Quote Tweet
I want to reiterate my statement from yesterday that the politicization of science and targeting of scientists we’re observing is deeply concerning and will not stand. At the same time, we need scientists more than ever, so to the budding ones, do not let this discourage you! twitter.com/cspan/status/1…
23
283
Our attempts to challenge their conclusions were invariably rejected without review medrxiv.org/content/10.110 Waning of infection-blocking immunity with seasonality in transmission is sufficient to explain the dynamics collateralglobal.org/article/how-se
Quote Tweet
Replying to @FraserNelson
There was an early Warwick study suggesting EOTO made things worse - but this theory disproven by later data.
Image
8
225
Thank you, Molly
Quote Tweet
'This is really devastating for children.' @UsforThemUK co-founder Molly Kingsley reacts to news that English secondary school pupils will have to wear face masks in classrooms again. @ianpaynesport | @lensiseethrough
Embedded video
2:56
4
207
This article misrepresents our views
Quote Tweet
Really important article on the polarisation of public scientific discourse in covid, dominated by extreme views Needless to say it’s not representative of most scientists It’s just what generates most clicks It was never zero covid vs do nothing thetimes.co.uk/article/warrin
2
152
1. To my mind, the only coherent explanation for the dynamics of SARS-CoV-2 in most global settings is that it played out as a classic coronavirus (SIRS with seasonality), with the first peak occurring in many regions before March 2020
Quote Tweet
It is indeed telling that they will not engage directly with me and the tone of their messages is quite shocking. I’m happy to discuss the issues directly with them as Twitter is not the best platform for it. I'll follow through with some points they will need to consider. twitter.com/GladiatrixRedu…
7
145
A lovely reason to break my Twitter silence -
Quote Tweet
New episode today with @SunetraGupta from @OxfordBiology talking to @Joe_Woodman1999 about modelling epidemics! Listen below: open.spotify.com/episode/3YE6p2 linktr.ee/oxpods
9
133
It is indeed telling that they will not engage directly with me and the tone of their messages is quite shocking. I’m happy to discuss the issues directly with them as Twitter is not the best platform for it. I'll follow through with some points they will need to consider.
Quote Tweet
Replying to @whippletom @freddiesayers and 2 others
@sunetragupta as this group of men hasn't had the courtesy to put their questions (and deeply sexist assertions) directly to you, I thought I would offer you the opportunity to respond.
3
119
This does not do justice to this wonderful book but perhaps it is a sign that the LRB are starting to appreciate how consummately lockdowns disrespect left wing values
Quote Tweet
lrb.co.uk/the-paper/v43/ Tks John Lanchester for reviewing The Covid Consensus in @LRB. Only a 4-word review ("A bracing anti-lockdown polemic"). But 4 words is progress. It represents liberal media's acknowledgement of a valid anti-lockdown position which is hard to criticise
10
111
We should have listened to Prof Muliyil and other humble individuals like him who only wanted to reduce human suffering
Quote Tweet
Prof Gupta stating what Muliyil said more than a year earlier; imagine if we’d treated this pandemic differently, w/ protection of the weak AND the wage earner: twitter.com/timesradio/sta
1
97
Thank you for your support and for your excellent contributions to the general debate
Quote Tweet
Just donated to the good people at Collateral Global. If you are also concerned by both the impact and precedent of global lockdowns, please consider giving whatever amount you can. Learn about CG here: collateralglobal.org And consider donating here: justgiving.com/campaign/colla
4
98
Grammatical mistakes are such a good reason to retweet - With due respect, when I took up my pen to sign the GBD what I thinking of were the millions who would die of poverty and neglect rather than those who might suffer from the withdrawal of bodily autonomy
Quote Tweet
With due respect, when I took up my pen to sign the GBD what I thinking of of the millions who would die of poverty and neglect rather than those whose who might suffer from the withdrawal of bodily autonomy twitter.com/SunetraGupta/s…
17
97
With due respect, when I took up my pen to sign the GBD what I thinking of of the millions who would die of poverty and neglect rather than those whose who might suffer from the withdrawal of bodily autonomy
Quote Tweet
Just for the record, I have no problem with mandates (I argued with the PHE about implementing a measles vaccine mandate which they rejected) as long as they are an enactment of the social contract. I would happily accept an age-specific mandate if it protected children twitter.com/leoniedelt/sta…
32
93
Particularly as a close friend of 35 years…
Quote Tweet
Replying to @DrJBhattacharya
Finally, I wonder what Woolhouse thinks of the behavior of top scientific bureaucrats, politicians, and the media smearing and deplatforming me, @MartinKulldorff, @SunetraGupta and so many others. Should we not have had this discussion without prejudice in 2020? 5/5
2
95
Quote Tweet
Replying to @T_Brautigan
We wrote the @gbdeclaration in october 2020 because we knew there would be a winter wave, and we pointed out lockdown harms in some detail in the interviews and debates that followed. We called for focused protection of vulnerable people, not 'let it rip'. If this was your… Show more
3
94
6. The notion that lockdowns worked to stop spread of infection does not resist scrutiny at present although they may have offered focused protection.
Quote Tweet
5. The apparent “mildness’ of Omicron is most likely to due to most people having acquired immunity against severe disease by then due to exposure or vaccination and not an intrinsic property of the virus population itself. twitter.com/SunetraGupta/s…
6
88
John Bird is one of my heroes - first came to know of him on Radio 3 speaking with eloquence and passion about how classical music transformed his life - underscoring how much we owe it to underprivileged children to give them an education in the Arts
Quote Tweet
🚨 Lockdown will trigger homelessness tsunami 225,000 face eviction “We’re in the midst of a perfect storm - rising energy costs, universal credit cut, end of furlough, lockdown job losses... I am very very worried.” Watch the podcast with John Bird: patreon.com/sketchnoteson
Image
2
79
Thank you, Molly - and keep up the good work!
Quote Tweet
Replying to @karamballes
We were honoured that @SunetraGupta and @DrJBhattacharya contributed, along with many others, to The Children’s Inquiry. They are two of the most inspiring souls I’ve ever met. The abuse they faced, and its awful consequences, will be recalled as one of history’s great tragedies.
1
78
5. The apparent “mildness’ of Omicron is most likely to due to most people having acquired immunity against severe disease by then due to exposure or vaccination and not an intrinsic property of the virus population itself.
Quote Tweet
Replying to @SunetraGupta
3. We were not in a position to evaluate the IFR in March 2020, although the skew in age was obvious - seroprevalence studies (which I put my money on – and, yes, I was wrong!) did not provide a clear indication of the level of exposure in a community
14
74
These are the points they will need to consider: 2. When I said that the epidemic was on its way out, I did not mean there wouldn’t be a second wave – why would I have risked so much to suggest a way of dealing with a resurgence if I thought it had just gone away?
Quote Tweet
1. To my mind, the only coherent explanation for the dynamics of SARS-CoV-2 in most global settings is that it played out as a classic coronavirus (SIRS with seasonality), with the first peak occurring in many regions before March 2020 twitter.com/SunetraGupta/s…
6
67
4. Clearly more elderly and otherwise vulnerable people died than I expected in the UK and we should be asking why this happened but that does not mean the IFR is 0.9
Quote Tweet
Replying to @SunetraGupta
3. We were not in a position to evaluate the IFR in March 2020, although the skew in age was obvious - seroprevalence studies (which I put my money on – and, yes, I was wrong!) did not provide a clear indication of the level of exposure in a community
5
63
We are looking for an immunologist (highly motivated and independent, of course) to join our universal flu vaccine programme:
Quote Tweet
Job Details my.corehr.com/pls/uoxrecruit
5
40
As you must know I have great respect for your opinions, but I would maintain that it is human dignity we hold onto - as Oedipus and the great tragedies affirm - rather than bodily autonomy
37
41
If it makes any difference at all, I cannot think of anyone whose tweets I look forward to reading more than yours. I’ve also found quite useful, in my darker moments, to remember that Rilke accused us of being wasters of sorrows.
42
Just to be clear, I am addressing Danny Altmann here
Quote Tweet
So disappointing to have to battle this out in the media rather than through a phonecall, Danny, but here are some explainers on what herd immunity actually means and how it is independent of the rate of loss of immunity collateralglobal.org/article/how-se collateralglobal.org/article/mini-l
1
38
With due respect, when I took up my pen to sign the GBD, I thinking of of the millions who would die of poverty and neglect rather than those who might suffer from the withdrawal of bodily autonomy
Quote Tweet
With due respect, when I took up my pen to sign the GBD what I thinking of of the millions who would die of poverty and neglect rather than those whose who might suffer from the withdrawal of bodily autonomy twitter.com/SunetraGupta/s…
3
34
None of us has the full skill set to determine what strategy was optimal but it should have been clear from the outset that lockdowns would cause more harm than good.
4
38
Thanks, Petra!
Quote Tweet
In the first podcast in our series launched yesterday our own @petrakle speaks to @SunetraGupta in ‘Progress towards a universal flu vaccine: understanding the many 'hats' of the influenza virus’ #vaccineswork soundcloud.com/user-789387211
6
27
3. We were not in a position to evaluate the IFR in March 2020, although the skew in age was obvious - seroprevalence studies (which I put my money on – and, yes, I was wrong!) did not provide a clear indication of the level of exposure in a community
5
30
So glad to see this go into 2nd ed - with the perfect subtitle
Quote Tweet
@battleforeurope and I excited to announce the coauthored 2nd edition of The Covid Consensus with new subtitle: The Global Assault on Democracy and the Poor -- a Critique from the Left: hurstpublishers.com/catalogues/aut (p40) Tks as always @MikeDwyerMike
2
29
Very good point. The first consideration is if it is logical. The second - which is more delicate - is whether it is ethical. This is the framework within which to place our desire for individual liberty.
31
28
How absolutely wonderful
Quote Tweet
I did a home recording for the first time today - ‘purano sei diner katha’, Tagore’s lovely reimagining of ‘Auld Lang Syne’. I recorded it on my iPhone and it has no enhancements or edits. It’s an informal offering, and I apologise for glitches or lapses: youtu.be/0uXNEzKsKqM
1
17
The credit here should go to Craig Thompson for going beyond simply testing the predictions of our model to developing a pipeline for identifying antigenic targets for a universal influenza vaccine
Quote Tweet
Why don't we yet have a universal flu vaccine and how can we fix that? Professor @SunetraGupta from @UniofOxford's @OxZooDept writes in Nature about her latest research into influenza, which OUI is helping get into the wider world. naturemicrobiologycommunity.nature.com/users/175433-s
14
There is absolutely no reason to invoke lockdowns (voluntary or otherwise) to explain the patterns observed - a simple SIRS model with seasonality will faithfully reproduce them (Epi 101)
1
13
It is this disjunction between reducing individual risk (which is completely feasible) and stopping spread at a population level (which is not) that is confusing everyone.
1
9
It has a big (although transient) effect on endemic diseases (as we saw) but hardly any effect on the dynamics of a newly introduced pathogen. Think of the potential energy of the system as the difference between the proportion immune and the herd immunity threshold.
2
8