Stefan MolyneuxVerified account

You’ve insisted your tweet was merely a question and not a conclusion, so why should anybody be required to make an argument when criticizing it? If you were just asking a question, this isn’t a debate. You don’t need an argument if the other side takes no position.

Not a rebuttal

Rt. It’s hard to argue against factual statements.

Your Tweet was not an argument, so it doesn't necessitate that it's replies are arguments.

Because it is a fact?

A argument is a statement which is said to be further backed by proof. A thesis is an argument. The argument, "You are crazy" is the thesis and the supporting facts are this tweet.

YOU did not make an argument therefore there’s no need to make a counter argument. YOU made a ridiculous analogy and tried to pass it off as logic.

You’re right. It’s not an argument. It’s a statement of observed reality, aka fact.

So your agreeing with what she says. You're saying no argument needed

It is in fact an argument.

You’re right. Just a fact that’s been stated