Just to be clear: Hillary announced a bold new plan that actually means mandatory civil conscription for all. But Trump's the Nazi.
Recruiting 5m out of ~100m 18-45 year olds in the US, once, is one thing. 5m (or 2.5m or even 1m) *every* year is something else.
-
-
As far as time commitment goes, that's a big question mark. Military reservists still have 5 months of training up front.
-
If it's just a weekend of training + email address, some kind of Hillary's Young Adventurers' Club, not sinister, but pointless.
-
Website language seems pretty clear about min time commitment (50,100hrs). I'll concede you're mostly correct about the age thing...
-
But the fact that it's 1-2hrs/wk volunteer work means plenty of people cld do for multiple years. Also, the numbers proposed in...
-
...a campaign prop. don't really reflect reality, or what she actly intends (vs. advertises). Either way, this isn't Nazi policy.
-
There's a Washington faction that's agitated to bring back some kind of "service" conscription since the end of the draft.
-
Every ten years or so, they make a new push for it. Last time around it was McCain, I think.
-
You're reading her plan as far more than she really expects or wants. I read it as rather less. We'll have to disagree.
- 3 more replies
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.
. Banned in Sweden. SubGenius, Zhuangist, white-hat troll. Defrocked mathematician. Brain problems.