And we're all learning to watch what we say and who we say it to, for fear of a broken robot taking away our friends and our reputation in the name of "trust and safety". We got a free market in totalitarianism.
-
-
Now compare that to an open marketplace where lots of different people go to pursue lots of different purposes. If the market is to be truly open, ie useful for many purposes not defined in advance by the owner, the rules must be a lot weaker.
-
Instead of the grocery shop's one basic transaction, owner selling to customer, the market has to allow many transactions, visitor A interacting with visitor B. In a liberal society, the guiding principle for the latter kind of transaction is _consent_.
-
ie, if A and B want to interact, the owner should generally not interfere. Now, if A _doesn't_ want to interact with B, that's a problem, and the owner may need to intervene. Thus one has police. Online, we have mute and block.
-
But where things really get complicated is if A and B want to interact, and C doesn't want them to. This can get ugly, particularly if C forms a large gang and stomps around the marketplace demanding the right to examine and forbid all transactions.
-
In a liberal society, this is generally regarded as a failure. C gaining power is good for C, bad for A and B, and bad for the health of the commons, because A and B are less able to interact for mutual benefit (and may seek coercive power themselves).
-
In short, politicization and morality enforcement both damage the power of ordinary people to seek beneficial interactions. They also become cripplingly expensive as the size of the commons increases, and tend to degenerate into banditry.
-
Anyway, this is just a sketch. For further consideration, I'd start with JS Mill: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_Liberty
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.
. Banned in Sweden. SubGenius, Zhuangist, white-hat troll. Defrocked mathematician. Brain problems.