Skoll Shorties

judged for what she did before she died to Arthas? or judged now that she is a "living" magical corpse? or strickly refering to dying IN the shadowlands regardless of your vital state when you enter it? O.o

I think you're very much judge overall of what you do both dead and alive which could be a hiccup so to speak when you go the Shadowlands. You're a much different person when you're Undead to how you were when you were fully alive.

Yeah, it was one of her best moments - making her wrong but also a position where this can refer to how Garrosh treated undead during his invasion to Gilneas, which was that event in the lore that positioned the ideology and philosophy of both Warchiefs.

I used this quote and a power phrase of "Stand in the ashes of a trillion dead souls and ask the ghosts if honor matters. The silence is your answer." in plague's RP.

But HASNT she been sending everyone to the Maw without judgement? Like everyone that’s died during the war was bypassed straight to the Maw I think, because of Sylvanas’s deal So I don’t believe she’s wrong at all

Technically she's right but also she's wrong. She's only right because she knows the machine of death is broken. But had it worked correctly Saurfang would've been sent probably to Maldraxxus rather than the Maw.