Skoll Shorties

Anduin could become a Light fanatic or fall to the Void. I wanna see it! How about the Alliance commits some atrocities and the Horde helps it restore its honour, rather than the other way around!

So we have the same story all over again? Boring. Can we, you know - develop - on some point and not having the "I want you too" mentality? The Horde was an instable alliance with different morals and fragile idenitity. Now it can change and we can have a different setting

It already changed - almost 20 years ago in Warcraft III. That Blizzard chose to make the Horde the villains of the story again, not once, but twice, invalidates the original redemption story of the orcs and Thrall's arc.

Instead of exploring evil Horde for the fourth time we can see what happens to the races of the Alliance if their morals get subverted. Their faith in the Light, their belief in law and justice - these can and must be twisted to evil, to show that neither faction is good or bad.

It adds nothing to the plot though. The only aspect you change is "Well its now your time", which is, in itself boring - as we had this already. To add up, no Alliance race truly has strong expansionistic ambitions - besides regaining their own homeland

It will be different aesthetically and ideologically. Self-assured righteousness and fanaticism instead of desperate desire for a better life for your people (Garrosh), or... wanting to kill people to feed your death daddy (Sylvanas)? Sinister inquisitors and paladins, etc

If anything they're clearly setting up a divide between Tyrande, Anduin and members of the Alliance. Tyrande wants vengeance for Teldrassil and clearly shows cracks in the ranks of the Alliance. The Alliance being divided is something new and not yet done before for them.

The Alliance being divided was already a theme in Pandaria, when Varian had to take actions against Jaina and Anduin. Its not entirely new to this point. To add up, Tyrande is not alone in her call for vegance, everyone besides Anduin understands her at this point.