Skoll Shorties

If bringing in races is a metric of a great Warcheif then the same can be credited to Sylvanas - she brought in the Forsaken, the Blood Elves, and who’s current leadership and understanding of their culture brought the Nightborne into their ranks too

She lead the Forsaken in seeking the Horde for protection when the Alliance killed her own emissaries - it was ultimately Thrall’s choice but if she had not had the balls to lead them to begin with and to go to the Horde, who had no reason to trust them, they would be extinct

I'm not saying Sylvanas is a poor Leader. Quite the opposite actually. What I am saying is Sylvanas is no the proper person to be Warchief.

Not really. A Warchief the Horde needs is somebody like Thrall who can please all sides without pissing off the other. She is holding up a crumbling castle right now. I wished Slyvanas to bring the Horde to victory but her version of victory isn't what the Horde should want.

It does not need a Warcheif like Thrall who will purposely punish his own people and set it up to rely on Alliance handouts at the cost of their own freedom and independence. Thrall then deserted and went neutral right when they needed him. That’s a Warcheif NO Horde needs

Thrall went neutral to save the World of Azeroth from splitting apart and then came back to help the horde when it was needed the most... Thrall kept order and kept the Horde from crumbling apart. He's something the Horde could need right now.

However you wanna spin it my friend to make yourself feel better, it doesn’t change the fact that Thrall himself accepted it was a mistake to leave the Horde to Garrosh as Warcheif: that all but confirms, by his own admission, that Thrall abandoned the Horde when it needed him