The Kavanaugh seat, if we’re doing proportional representation of “who we are as a country”, could technically be the mystery seat. Fine: unfair. But let’s address the 3 Jews (there shouldn’t be any Jews on the SC going by “who we are as a nation” reasoning) taking 3 seats first
-
-
Show this thread
-
Why does 2% of our population get 33% of our Supreme Court seats? How’s that fair?
Show this thread -
“But Judaism is just a religion!” Fine. Let’s play religious identity politics. We have 5 Catholics & 3 Jews. By “who we are as a nation”, we should have 5 Protestants, 2 Catholics, and 2 atheist/agnostic/irreligious justices. All other religions should have no seats at all.
Show this thread -
And by the way: that last tweet was for the sake of argument. It is not “just a religion”. 1) they’ll tell you that themselves (I’m not white I’m Jewish) 2) Wikipedia even lists Jews on their world wide list of ethnic groups They are distinct & hoarding 33% of SC seats.
Show this thread -
Another fun fact: 8 of the 113 Supreme Court justices that have ever served have been Jewish. 7%. Despite them only being 2% of population now & (as an example), less than half of one percent of population as recently as 1880. Right historical wrongs: no more jewish justices.
Show this thread -
That is how this works right? “Well women & poc have been historically marginalized. Now is their turn on the court to make up for the past record.” Again: Jews already gobbled up 7%. To retroactively correct that, we can have no more Jewish justices til number balance out again
Show this thread -
The first SC Justice was confirmed in 1789. 229 years ago. We have had 113 justices total. There have been 8 Jews. If we want that number back to 2% (to say nothing of lower percentages of Jews in US historically), we have to have no new Jewish justices til after 400th confirmed
Show this thread -
Really puts things in perspective if we’re playing “the court should represent who we are as a nation by identity”. In 229 years we’ve had 113. To rebalance Jews just to today’s 2% number they “should” have, they shouldn’t be eligible again til after number 400. Maybe 500 years.
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
I am so hoping the next few seats are for right-wing Protestants. That's 'who we are' in America.
-
A flyover state school grad, a Texas law grad, an LA Basin Armenian Pentecostal. Someone from Iowa, or Kansas, or Alabama. Anything other than Ivy hive mind. Just for kicks. Tennessee, who likes squirrel. a public school grad. A Baptist. A Church of Christ deacon.
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
Mystery Seat for the Mystery Meat
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
-
-
J's should know better than to complain about overrepresentation by other groups. They *really* do not want to open that door, since the next chapter will be sobbing and loud wails of "antisemitism" (aka embarrassing truths).
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
-
-
(((They))) count the Jews as whites when it serves their purposes.
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.