it's just a bare assertion that, axiomatically, the US and Israel are Good, and Hamas and the Taliban are Bad, and it is always inherently illegitimate to compare the former's actions to the latter's. it's a declaration of _faith,_ not a real engagement with anything Omar said.
-
-
Show this thread
-
Hamas is a government. the Taliban was a government, and probably will be again before long. if your argument is "you can't compare the actions of THESE governments to the actions of THOSE governments" you're going to need some actual reasons.
Show this thread -
"they're designated terrorist organizations!" yeah, they're designated _by us_. we designated them. we put them on a list and then said "oops! we checked the list and you're on it, you're terrorists now, sorry, That's The Rules".
Show this thread -
lots of governments (it would probably be safe to say all) do bad things from time to time. many governments do VERY bad things, rather frequently! here's a big secret: ours does, too.
Show this thread -
you can't start from the premise "we're Good and they're Bad", also conclude "we're Good and they're Bad", and then expect anyone to take your position seriously. it's not a serious position. it's the reasoning of a toddler.
Show this thread -
if you have an adult theory of mind and you understand that other people's thoughts are distinct from your own, and they don't automatically start from all the same assumptions you do, you know this kind of "argument" is meaningless.
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.




