Ok, I'm going to attempt a really long thread in response to this...https://twitter.com/QiaochuYuan/status/1118773759177924608 …
-
-
I think there are at least a few different components of how someone could react to “Children of Moloch” memeplexes, and folks could get tangled up between them. (I may bungle this and would be glad of any help; words remain broken as usual)
Prikaži ovu nit -
Some things that make decent sense to me: 1. Molochian patterns freak me the fuck out, man! I am frightened, I am horrified. 2. Molochian patterns could kill me, and could destroy human civilization as we know it. 3. I want to live and thrive, and I want the same for humanity.
Prikaži ovu nit -
Flinching from horror has been adaptive for human survival! Flinch away from misplaced blood and shit → get fewer infections → have more surviving babies. I figure, treat it as a signal, as you would pain - "alert! this situation is not friendly to human survival"
Prikaži ovu nit -
And also, the value of a signal is dependent on its context. We’re now in a situation where there is no “away.” Reflexive flinching is no longer enough.
Prikaži ovu nit -
And we’ve had cultures clash and break down such that an action can mean “loving care” in one framework and “horror like unto misplaced bodily fluids” in another. Crazy-making!
Prikaži ovu nit -
If someone’s very reactive, getting some space between the gut reaction, and the meaning of it, and the choice of action, can help. If someone’s very numb, getting more connection with the gut reaction, and the meaning of it, and the choice of action, can help.
Prikaži ovu nit -
Now, here’s where things could get confused, if folks went on to: 4A: Moloch is Evil and some other things are Good; Moloch is entirely contaminated and some other things are pure. There’s dualism for you! And a whole bunch of stuff around attachment and aversion.
Prikaži ovu nit -
(This, I think, is why Scott Alexander’s post about “The Goddess of Everything Else” didn’t quite land for me? Because it’s about getting entirely free of the Darwinian charnel ground, and I think that’s a confusion.)
Prikaži ovu nit -
Or, folks could add “but it’s hopeless” to #3 and fall into a trap of: 4B: Moloch is Evil and no other things are Good. There’s nihilism for you:https://meaningness.com/nihilism-anxiety …
Prikaži ovu nit -
And there’s something here about… “horror that paralyzes” (like Lovecraftian nihilism) vs “horror that galvanizes” (like Feynman at the Oak Ridge plant, telling folks to store those nuclear materials further apart!)
Prikaži ovu nit -
Now, I want to pull in a few examples from biology & ecology, to point at how all this goes way deeper than any modern Moloch. (Perhaps a bit of bending some assumption back and forth until it snaps?)
Prikaži ovu nit -
Ok, so! - A pink flower - A green caterpillar covered in small white things - An iridescent beetle - A retrovirus (diagram) Any particular reactions so far, right off the bat?pic.twitter.com/3JD7vWxMCj
Prikaži ovu nit -
Let’s start with the flower. Maybe you find it beautiful, and you’re pleased?pic.twitter.com/qT4EYSY49c
Prikaži ovu nit -
Now you find out it is Striga, witchweed, a parasitic plant that sucks nutrients from cereal crops. It destroys the equivalent of 15 million meals per day in Africa. https://www.wur.nl/en/newsarticle/Parasitic-plants-cause-huge-damage-to-rice-crops-in-Africa.htm … You might feel horror, sadness, anger, resolve? Is it still beautiful?pic.twitter.com/SgBhgfoIXM
Prikaži ovu nit -
Or, perhaps, you find a caterpillar, covered in cocoons of parasitoid wasps. The larvae have eaten it from the inside out, and emerged through its skin. It will die soon. What does that bring up?pic.twitter.com/6hmaYoSx0w
Prikaži ovu nit -
As a child, I felt the horror, and would try to remove the cocoons, not knowing it was already doomed.
Prikaži ovu nit -
(Darwin felt the horror: "I cannot persuade myself that a beneficent and omnipotent God would have designedly created parasitic wasps with the express intention of their feeding within the living bodies of Caterpillars.")
Prikaži ovu nit -
And yet. Without parasitoid wasps, and other diseases and predators that kill plant-eating insects, our own vital crops would fail. If baculoviruses did not liquefy caterpillars, human children would starve.
Prikaži ovu nit -
(Couldn’t find
#s for parasitoids specifically, but biological control provides half the value of food production! Cock et al. 2012 - PDF via Google Scholar, search doi 10.1079/PAVSNNR20127043 )pic.twitter.com/EtYfnhQEQa
Prikaži ovu nit -
-
-
It’s also a dung beetle! Does that change how you feel? (Phanaeus vindex - I’ve seen ‘em in Florida!)pic.twitter.com/o0WF6w9Yo8
Prikaži ovu nit -
Consider that different species would have different valences (attraction / aversion) to the same stimuli. If dung beetles wrote poetry, they would compose odes to the sweet fragrance of life-giving shit.
Prikaži ovu nit -
Dung beetle poets: "Shit, triumphant prize of victors! Shit, nourishing cradle for babies! The ox anus, glorious fountain from which all good things flow!"
Prikaži ovu nit -
And! Humans have worshipped scarabs, dung beetles. Without them, we’d be knee-deep in dung! Important for nutrient cycling.https://www.wired.com/2014/07/fantastically-wrong-dung-beetle-worship/ …
Prikaži ovu nit -
And, the retrovirus. What comes up for you? As humans, we're not on Team Virus, right? Viruses are terrifying, and sometimes deadly!pic.twitter.com/OdjJHTQDfr
Prikaži ovu nit -
Welp: http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/loom/2012/02/14/mammals-made-by-viruses/#.XLijHnUvw8o … Some of the key patterns that make you who you are, biologically, are made of ancient viruses. We wouldn’t be able to carry our babies in the womb, if it weren’t for viral DNA.
Prikaži ovu nit -
-
(((If you really, really, really want an extra-strength bonus mediation on grotesque Darwinian patterns juxtaposed with tenderness and meaning -- Just be aware that it's enacted by numberless cartoon spiders: https://youtu.be/FL0En5GQkbM?t=30 … )))
Prikaži ovu nit -
Contaminated and pure, sacred and profane start to break down, and build back up into something different. I don’t think there’s a “right” or “wrong” way to feel about these, before or after you know more about them. Many layers of meaning and story. It’s patterned and nebulous.
Prikaži ovu nit - Još 4 druga odgovora
Novi razgovor -
Čini se da učitavanje traje već neko vrijeme.
Twitter je možda preopterećen ili ima kratkotrajnih poteškoća u radu. Pokušajte ponovno ili potražite dodatne informacije u odjeljku Status Twittera.