Conversation

Replying to

8) Well, certainly FTX US, and Coinbase. But.... how about an ETH miner? They mine a block, include 3rd party transactions, and add it to the blockchain. That block might contain a trade on a DEX between 2 parties. Is the ETH miner "effectuating a transfer of digital assets"?

3

20

301

9) It sorta seems like it might be! And it is getting rewards for mining the block--there's the consideration. So as phrased, it's broad enough that it could include miners, stakers, noncustodial wallets, etc.

1

8

231

10) But the miners aren't really the ones responsible for the trade. They're just dutifully including whatever (possibly even encrypted or unparseable!) transactions they're told to. In the equities/broker realm, this is sort of the equivalent of the ISP (e.g. Comcast).

5

18

287

11) They're not specifically running an exchange or broker--they're just passing on and formalizing all the information in the network, a bit of which might happen to be trading related.

1

9

227

12) The impact of requiring centralized US exchanges to report is that taxable gains get reported to the IRS. The impact of requiring miners to report is... Well they probably _couldn't_ even do it. It won't increase tax; it'll just kill industry, or offshore it.

1

40

391

13) And, in fact, on most blockchains everything is public. So if you wanted tax reporting from it, an independent company would be just as well equipped as the blockchain infrastructure providers. Autonomous smart contracts, on the other hand, can't understand questions.

1

10

282

14) Now, there are still unresolved questions. Sure, the miners shouldn't be the ones reporting blockchain-based tax, but who _should_? How _do_ tax reporting and DEXes interface? I don't know! It's a complicated question. But miners aren't the answer.

3

14

230

15) So, what happened? Well, a *lot* of feedback of this sort has been given to the Senate, and there are revised versions begin considered.

1

5

203

16) In particular, versions clarifying that the people solely doing the following don't count: a) "validating distributed ledger transactions" b) "selling hardware or software for which the sole function is to permit a person to control private keys"

2

9

250

17) c) "developing digital assets or their corresponding protocols for use by other persons" Essentially, the amendment would clarify that building DeFi or blockchain products isn't like being a centralized broker, and wouldn't have to try to find and report on-chain trades.

1

8

176

18) This amendment successfully clarifies the largest issues, and guides the bill towards the straightforward targets for reporting: centralized US crypto exchanges.

11:26 PM · Aug 5, 2021Twitter Web App

Replying to

19) This amendment is *really* important: it is the difference between a reasonable bill that will probably reduce tax underreporting, and one that could cripple industries while failing to raise more tax.

6

33

319

20) Regulation is coming to crypto, and in some cases has long since come. We're excited to work with regulators to build out frameworks to accomplish their goals; to act as a reference if helpful; and to help give color on how provisions would fit in the industry.

4

13

209

21) ---------------- An addendum: what's up with your crypto tax basis? Normally, you'd expect a report from FTX like: " 1) Bob buys 10 BTC @ $10,000 each 2) Bob sells 10 BTC @ $12,000 each " In that case, Bob would likely have $20,000 of taxable profit.

3

7

148

22) But in crypto, you might instead get the following from an exchange: " 1) Bob deposits 10 BTC 2) Bob sells 10 BTC @ $12,000 each " So, Bob sold his BTC for $12k. What was the tax basis of it? How much did Bob make (or lose)?

2

11

196

23) Well the _real_ answer is, "we don't know". Bob sold his BTC on FTX, but he didn't buy it there! He bought it somewhere else, and then transferred it, on the blockchain, to FTX. FTX has to calculate a taxable income but doesn't all the necessary information to.

5

13

233

24) You could try to take the price of BTC at the time Bob deposited, but that probably wasn't really when he bought it. Maybe he bought it in 2017 for $4,000 each! Blockchain transfers make it so that each exchange isn't an isolate set of trading; they interact.

7

8

222

25) So to *really* know Bob's tax basis (or profit, or tax), you'd need to combine his records from *all* exchanges together: Coinbase: 1) Bob buys 10 BTC @ $9k each 2) Bob withdraws 10 BTC FTX: 3) Bob deposits 10 BTC 4) Bob sells 10 BTC @ $12k each --> $30k profit.

81

24

420

Replying to

What about holders of governance tokens for a DAO controlled DEX? Even with the amendment, would they be subject to the regulations? And what if the DEX is immutable vs upgradeable? That would seem relevant as well, yet seems very unclear from the wording.

2