Your claim was that because browser vendors haven't reached the same conclusion as @hanno (That commercial CAs are going to die), this proves they aren't an agent for the user. I think you've moved the goalposts here, no?
In the case of Safari, the EV UI actually *suppresses* the user's only easy way of seeing that the site is not the one they intended to visit.
-
-
In general, special UI presentation for EV is misleading to users, gives false sense of security and wrongly implies non-EV sites are less secure.
-
I don't disagree, but this has nothing to do with the thread you replied to and certainly doesn't prove that "browser people" don't care about users. Does your crypt() implementation support DES? Who's back pocket are you in to support DES in 2018?

-
FWIW I don't think they "don't care about users". I just think they give too much weight to interests of other parties who aren't the user. It's improving in some areas, but slowly.
-
So your argument is that by showing EV, they aren’t the user’s agent, but instead in the back pocket of CAs?
-
Not "in the back pocket". There's no conspiracy or conflict of interest here. I just claim they give to much weight to interests of parties they don't represent & are overly conflict-adverse in ways that fail users' interests.
-
And you believe supporting EV is an illustration of that?
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.
