So wait did anyone ever fix the whole "to cross a distance I must cross half the distance etc" all distance contain an infinite sum thing? Is the answer just that infinite sums can have finite results?
Conversation
in the mathematical model, yes, infinite sums (over either distance or time) can have finite results. in “the real world” (slightly less idealized model) it’s not at all clear that it’s possible ro infinitely subdivide space or time, or perform infinitely many actions
3
49
a thing that i think mathematicians and physicists don’t do a good job of conveying is that most of our use of large infinite objects like the real numbers is a matter of convenience. the infinite is a convenient approximation of the merely unimaginably large finite
7
2
46
wait
2
11
this is not a universal opinion to be clear but i think it’s quite defensible. doron zeilberger is notably very vocal about this: users.uoa.gr/~apgiannop/zei
2
24
well fuck
1
12
Replying to
lol sorry was this load-bearing i am happy to talk more
yeah i think people get hung up on 0.999... = 1 for a good reason, it relies on a specific ontology of what a number is and what an infinite sum is to be meaningful and true and that ontology wasn’t rigorously pinned down until the 19th century (by cauchy iirc)
1
6
Show replies
revisiting and this hits even better with olaf delivering it
i may be sad when this season ends
1
4
it has an extra charm to it don't it
2