As someone with an actual PhD in sociology, I'd say you shouldn't trust any sociologist who suggests sociology is a discipline full of fixed definitions & concepts. It isn't, and anybody who suggests otherwise should be sent back to remedial sociology class.https://twitter.com/tootsiekannah/status/973324950143578112 …
-
-
So long as you define your terms, use them in a logically consistent & coherent manner, you're good to go. (Though obviously that's not in the least bit a guarantee your concepts are going to describe the world accurately or be useful).
Show this thread -
Of course, if you define "racism" so that it refers to hierarchical relations between the sexes, people are going to think you're a ninny. But if you define "racism" so that it refers to racially motivated bigotry, then that wouldn't be - or shouldn't be - the case.
Show this thread -
So if you see any sociologist claiming the sociological definition of "racism" is prejudice plus power, or something like that, don't believe them. Call them on it. Ask them to specify the sociological authority that polices the correct use of sociological language.
Show this thread -
I need to finish this by saying that none of this means that the "prejudice plus power" formulation isn't useful. It is useful. The loathing of a black slave for white people isn't the same thing as white people's loathing of black slaves, for example.
Show this thread -
It's just you don't get to tell the sociologist or social psychologist who is using the term "racism" in its normal sense to mean racially motivated bigotry that they are somehow using language wrong. They're not.
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
> There is no sociology police to enforce such claims. Unfortunately, purveyors of this dogma sometimes do have enforcers as real as any other kind of police, and there are real consequences for those in relationships with them for calling their bullshit.
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.