Curiously, this sort of response is structurally identical to right-wing denials that social deprivation might be a causal factor in crime. https://twitter.com/GodDoesnt/status/915751113659383808 …
"Poverty can't be a causal factor explaining crime because the vast majority of people who live in poverty don't commit crimes."
-
-
It's a stupid argument, of course. Exposure to the sun can't be causal factor for melanoma, because the vast majority of sunbathers... etc;
Show this thread -
Part of the problem is people think in terms of causes rather than causal factors. Mental illness can (obviously) be a causal factor...
Show this thread -
explaining a horrible crime. But it's never going to be the whole story. Mental illness exists in a particular socio-cultural context.
Show this thread -
It's entirely consistent - & plausible? - to suppose that mass killings might be a manifestation of "toxic masculinity" & mental illness.
Show this thread -
It's odd to see American "progressives" denying the possibility that mental illness might be a causal factor in these things.
Show this thread -
In my day, it was the Left arguing that mental distress might mitigate. Mind you, American culture has always been rather fond of vengeance.
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.