The reaction to Dr Lindsay's talk, & now the pushback against the CFI, perfectly demonstrates what happens when ideology trumps rationality.
-
@philosophyexp Have you considered that maybe his talk wasn't rational or good?
-
-
@philosophyexp I hope that's not a no :-) -
@mollydot It's the proportionality of the response that's the issue. This is his speech: http://bit.ly/15fskht . 1/ -
@philosophyexp I've read parts of it. I'll read it later; just on phne now. 1st thing I read was his response & I didn't think much of it -
@mollydot The resp. he apologised for? The issue isn't whether his speech is any good - lots aren't - it's the proportionality of response. -
@philosophyexp He apologised for his response? Didn't know that. Not following it. Have seen yr tweets,his response & a couple of anti posts -
@mollydot He apologises here (but I'm not sure what response you're talking about): http://bit.ly/15fuk9p -
@PhilosophyExp Reading his response now, I can only say: My god, the man's an idiot. Wrong. Illogical. Wrong. Misquote? Uncharitable reading -
@PhilosophyExp And that's without having read Watson's post. His post doesn't stand up by itself. - 3 more replies
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.