I think he's overreaching in his final paragraph, but yes, his point that he wasn't constructing an experiment is entirely fair. My bad.
-
.
@PhilosophyExp But not making excuses is to your credit. And it's to Nugent's that he accepts some of the blame for the way he wrote it. /2
@Metamagician Thx. It's true the way I read it was framed by PZ's take. But... if you're going to criticize forcefully, as I did, you've...1