How does this translate to Australia? In Newtown, a gentrified suburb on Gadigal land, young White men around us physically jumped in glee, some acting out the punches on screen. Visceral responses to films are fine! But why might Joker feel liberation? Hegemonic masculinitypic.twitter.com/QCVstDYQB3
-
Show this thread
-
Hegemonic masculinity reflects how some representations of masculinity win out over other expressions of manhood. Film (and other cultural insitutions, like sport) assert narrow ideas of what it means to be 'a man.' Joker dresses up Arthur's escalating violence as emancipationpic.twitter.com/4jBmQMAhqS
17 replies 41 retweets 259 likesShow this thread -
Environmentalism is one example of anti-hegemonic masculinity. The movement preaches (though does not easily achieve) gender equality (cf https://www.allenandunwin.com/browse/books/academic-professional/sociology/Masculinities-RW-Connell-9781741145199 …) Weeks after global climate change protests, there is still an audience keen to cheer Arthur's destruction & misogynypic.twitter.com/BkLH865GDn
13 replies 12 retweets 161 likesShow this thread -
Can you be an environmentalist & still enjoy Joker? Yes! But as bell hooks tells us, we can enjoy films but remain critical. Let's continue Arthur fixates on Sophie, to 'humanise' the character. The interactions are examples of gender violence, but not presented this waypic.twitter.com/uwPXhhADzp
10 replies 23 retweets 222 likesShow this thread -
*Spoiler* Arthur stalks Sophie. She's coquettish in response. Sophie is a single mum, but she's seen making herself available to Arthur for sex (after he's killed), & taking care of his emotions. The interactions play on the audience, but the film excuses this as mental illnesspic.twitter.com/NbYWnBhmG4
77 replies 16 retweets 164 likesShow this thread -
*Spoiler* Arthur kills Penny after finding out that: 1/ Due to mental illness, she believed Thomas Wayne was his father; 2/ he was actually adopted; 3/ she was a victim of intimate partner violence and "allowed" Arthur to be physically abused by the same man. Misogyny rulespic.twitter.com/dBHwG2xp6M
25 replies 12 retweets 197 likesShow this thread -
Joker relies on a dangerous misogynist trope; that women 'lie' about pregnancy for financial gain. Actually, misattributed parentage occurs in 1% of cases, mostly due to complex relationships, not money (https://tapri.org.au/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/v13n2_1gilding.pdf …) Still, Penny deserves to die by this logicpic.twitter.com/bcbh1IbsA2
37 replies 22 retweets 216 likesShow this thread -
44 women have been killed in Australia in 2019 (https://www.facebook.com/notes/destroy-the-joint/counting-dead-women-australia-2019-we-count-every-known-death-due-to-violence-ag/2582150351832693/ …). 5 women in 1 week (https://womensagenda.com.au/latest/five-women-were-murdered-in-australia-in-seven-days/ …) 1/3 of women experience emotional abuse by a partner & 1/4 sexual and intimate partner violence (https://theconversation.com/study-confirms-intimate-partner-violence-leading-health-risk-factor-for-women-67772 …) How is Joker an 'anti-hero' for us?pic.twitter.com/DVUvYXEkg7
29 replies 21 retweets 198 likesShow this thread -
Joker presents Arthur as an 'every man' whose poverty demands justice. It demotes Black women to stereotypes (https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/entry/lets-talk-about-the-black-women-in-joker_n_5d9605dae4b0da7f6622abc7?ri18n=true …) Above all, Joker inverts gender & race in its 'social commentary.' Black women in USA & Australia are central to civil movements. Not in Jokerpic.twitter.com/X1Fw9sVUbA
15 replies 25 retweets 229 likesShow this thread -
Replying to @OtherSociology
Thank you for this critique. Good to know which cinema audiences to avoid.
1 reply 0 retweets 1 like
It was an overwhelming reaction, that's for sure!
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.