Let's talk about representations of race, gender & ableism in Joker and how to situate a critical reading in the local Australian context I saw the film last night in Newtown, Sydney, where the mostly White audience erupted in rapturous clapping. We'll explore this reactionpic.twitter.com/GeGigvfxbJ
-
-
44 women have been killed in Australia in 2019 (https://www.facebook.com/notes/destroy-the-joint/counting-dead-women-australia-2019-we-count-every-known-death-due-to-violence-ag/2582150351832693/ …). 5 women in 1 week (https://womensagenda.com.au/latest/five-women-were-murdered-in-australia-in-seven-days/ …) 1/3 of women experience emotional abuse by a partner & 1/4 sexual and intimate partner violence (https://theconversation.com/study-confirms-intimate-partner-violence-leading-health-risk-factor-for-women-67772 …) How is Joker an 'anti-hero' for us?pic.twitter.com/DVUvYXEkg7
Show this thread -
Joker presents Arthur as an 'every man' whose poverty demands justice. It demotes Black women to stereotypes (https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/entry/lets-talk-about-the-black-women-in-joker_n_5d9605dae4b0da7f6622abc7?ri18n=true …) Above all, Joker inverts gender & race in its 'social commentary.' Black women in USA & Australia are central to civil movements. Not in Jokerpic.twitter.com/X1Fw9sVUbA
Show this thread -
Joker re-imagines that a White man can lead social revolution, when it's actually Black women who've been at the forefront of social movements before, during and after, the 1970s context of the film In Joker, Black women are passive & unlikeable subjects so that Arthur can risepic.twitter.com/chAO7dxqIU
Show this thread -
Joker contrives White heroism, so that non-Indigenous people in Newtown clap, while oblivious of Aboriginal women heroes, like Dulcie Flower (http://bit.ly/Dulcie_Flower ), Coleen Shirley Perry Smith (pic, http://bit.ly/Mum_Shirl ), Ruby Langford Ginibi (http://bit.ly/Langford_Ginibi )pic.twitter.com/9jRnijE5kY
Show this thread -
Arthur rages against 'the system' which has cut off funding to his mental healthcare in fictional Gotham. Yesterday, as we watched this film in Australia, poor & disabled people were subjected to renewed calls to shrink our public healthcare, via tax breaks to employers.
pic.twitter.com/26R2cbLW3vShow this thread -
Joker relies heavily on ableism. Arthur suffers from uncontrollable laughter (pseudobulbar affect, also refers to spontaenous crying). Colleagues & strangers make fun of him. But this is just a set-up to excuse his violence, reproducing the stereotype that mental illness=violencepic.twitter.com/mqoG1LRYc7
Show this thread -
Sexist ableism: Penny, who is a White woman, is mentally ill AND physically disabled. She's snuffed out to unburden Arthur as his carer & push his re-birth as Joker Audiences cheer Arthur's metamorphosis, as he transcends disability, used to selectively excuse violent White menpic.twitter.com/RMEHHNL1a0
Show this thread -
Back to the cheering Newtown audience: our nation's apathy for disabled people is epic, especially Aboriginal people who suffer most due to under-resourcing & institutional violence Would we clap for Others? Of course not. Disability is a prop to celebrate White men's hedonismpic.twitter.com/4PaMkvBt23
Show this thread -
Joker director, Todd Phillips, claims he was driven from making comedies due to 'woke culture.' Origins to this term is appropriation of Black activism & subsequent backlash (esp White men), who feel *aggrieved entitlement* to be sexist, racist, ableist, transphobic & homophobicpic.twitter.com/xMQkXbdIYO
Show this thread -
In light of Phillips' comments, Joker's pretence to class liberation is exposed as the same brand of nihilism fueling incel (involuntary celibate) ideology (https://www.pastemagazine.com/articles/2019/10/joker-todd-phillips.html …). Which is to say, this film is really just old-fashioned patriarchy rehashed as 'resistance.'
pic.twitter.com/4Kj3THHzqKShow this thread -
When Joker begins, we see protesters holding 'RESIST' signs - an allusion to anti-Trump protests in 2017. However the film ends with Joker's sycophants holding RESIST signs upside down. White patriarchy's co-opting of social protest, centring White violence, wins in the endpic.twitter.com/pimSvCVLKU
Show this thread -
Joker is entertaining. I've unpacked dynamics showing why the film is far from transformative cinema, as some White critics claim. E.g. See comparisons to 'Get Out'
, showing how White people are eager to assimilate Black excellence, esp in a film that undervalues Black womenpic.twitter.com/XMu9TIKfFB
Show this thread -
Then there's the fact that the film evokes New York - which is 27.5% Latin, 25% Black, 12% Asian, among Others - but a White man is elevated to protest warrior
Joaquin Phoenix's performance is as commanding as everyone has been raving, BUT his portrayal is not without issuespic.twitter.com/cK49MGsisS
Show this thread -
Phoenix is very talented & could've rendered a profound performance if Arthur had simply been an angry, isolated man. But he was portrayed as disabled to give the filmmaker license on his violence, banking on accolade given to able-bodied actors using disability to gain sympathypic.twitter.com/PnNsZfEVRD
Show this thread -
Enjoy the film - I did, to a point - but don't mistake it as social commentary. It speaks only to White men who think the world owes them free reign; invites able-bodied people to cheer for caricatures of disability; & dresses up patriarchy as liberation. Joker does nothing newpic.twitter.com/7v9JruegwA
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
My ex girlfriend actually did this to her man before me: said she was getting an abortion then spent the $. Glad I stopped dating her. More common than you think.
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
-
-
I PERSONALLY HAVE HAD A WOMAN LIE ABOUT BEING PREGNANT IN MY LIFE. She squeezed me for THOUSANDS before one of her friends came forward and told me she was lying. WTF? You cant seriously be a Dr. Im convinced...
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
-
-
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
-
-
No. There's no logic. The scene is played to show Arthur's loss of his grip on reality. He begins to un attach himself from society and that will turn him into a psychotic criminal.
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
-
-
No she didnt....none of the people Arthur killed deserved it. That's kind of the point
-
Maybe the very first guy but it very quickly goes from self defense to murder
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.